Milwaukee’s Job Sprawl Mess: a Cautionary Tale

Remember how suburban office parks used to be all the rage? Their strongest selling point was that you didn’t have to pay to park at them. And if you lived in the suburbs anyway, you could avoid the hassle of going into the city, basically, ever. What could go wrong?

New Berlin is one of four major job centers in the Milwaukee area that is completely inaccessible via transit. Image: ##http://www.bizjournals.com/milwaukee/print-edition/2012/04/06/froedtert-plans-new-berlin-clinic.html?page=all## The Business Journal##
New Berlin is one of four major job centers in the Milwaukee area that is completely inaccessible via transit. Image: ##http://www.bizjournals.com/milwaukee/print-edition/2012/04/06/froedtert-plans-new-berlin-clinic.html?page=all##The Business Journal##

Well, Bruce Murphy at Urban Milwaukee explains a new study from Public Policy Forum [PDF] about the problems this kind of job sprawl has caused in his region:

Among city of Milwaukee residents, 13 percent of workers do not have access to a personal automobile, compared with 6 percent of workers in Milwaukee County’s suburbs and 4 percent or less in Waukesha, Ozaukee, and Washington counties, the study notes.

Cuts in service by the Milwaukee County Transit System have resulted in a 22 percent decline in total annual bus miles between 2000 and 2012, causing “tens of thousands of jobs to become inaccessible via public transportation.”

The report finds there are 29 “job centers” in the four county area, locations where there are at least 10,000 jobs. More than a third — 11 job centers which employ more than 204,000 people — are outside Milwaukee County and relatively inaccessible for workers from this county. [Four are totally transit inaccessible.]

Suburban and particularly ex-urban development has been structured in a way that makes homes unaffordable for potential workers, doesn’t offer them much in the way of apartments or rental units, and locates businesses in areas that are not easily connected via fixed bus routes.

Compounding the problem, the new sprawling job centers just aren’t easy to serve via transit. The report notes these locations typically don’t meet the 22 passengers per bus hour the region uses as a minimum to justify service. Meanwhile, other smaller-scale solutions like commuter van pools have had mixed results.

“Route extensions to suburban job hubs, rather than new routes are most likely to meet this standard,” writes Murphy.”But given the cuts in federal grants that have occurred, the only potential funding source would be the Milwaukee County property tax.”

Elsewhere on the Network today: Mobilizing the Region lists a surprising number of areas where transit riders’ monthly commute costs can exceed $130 — the places, in other words, where riders will lose out if Congress doesn’t renew the transit commuter tax benefit at its current level. Systemic Failure reports that it’s not just state and local agencies focused on surface transportation that are using make-believe traffic projections: Airports, as well, cling to fantastically optimistic and demonstrably incorrect projections to justify projects of equally dubious merit. And Urban Cincy outlines the decade of grassroots and political effort that made the Cincinnati Streetcar possible.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Fight for Better Access to Jobs in Detroit and Milwaukee, Using Buses

|
Low-income residents of Detroit and Milwaukee face formidable obstacles to job access. These two Rust Belt regions are consistently ranked among the most segregated in the country, and neither has a good transit system. In both regions, the places that have been growing and adding jobs fastest have been been overwhelmingly sprawling, suburban areas inaccessible to people without cars. A 2013 Brookings study […]

What Happens When Jobs Are Out of the Reach of Transit

|
The Milwaukee region has a big problem. Over the last few decades, most jobs were added in far-flung suburbs that tend to be completely inaccessible by public transit. Meanwhile, the majority of jobless workers live in Milwaukee, and many of them lack access to a car. At a recent meeting of regional leaders covered by […]

Will Milwaukee Fall for the Convention Center Shakedown?

|
This is how it begins: Local leaders in Milwaukee commissioned a study examining whether the city’s convention center is up to snuff. Surprise, surprise, reports Bruce Murphy at Urban Milwaukee: Hunden Strategic Partners, a consulting firm that loves convention centers, says Milwaukee really ought to be pumping a bunch of public money into expanding its convention facilities and a […]