The USA Streetsies: Looking Back at the Best and Worst of 2016

Wake County voters were among those across the country who elected to expand transit. Photo: Raleigh Chamber
Wake County voters were among those across the country who elected to expand transit. Photo: Raleigh Chamber

Last week we asked readers to help sort through the highs and lows of the past year in streets and transportation. Here’s what rose to the top of the polls, as well as our review of the heroes and villains of 2016.

Thanks for reading and enjoy the New Year — we’ll be back to our daily publishing schedule on Tuesday.

Best Sign of Progress: Voters Decide to Invest in Transit

If you’re looking for silver linings to the results from November 8, this is a good place to start. At the local level, voters did a lot to advance transit.

Major transit expansion measures passed in SeattleLos AngelesRaleigh, and IndianapolisAtlanta voters approved the first major expansion of MARTA in decades. Of the big transit initiatives on local ballots, only Detroit’s regional transit plan failed, and that was a very narrow defeat.

Biggest Local Failure: The D.C. Metro Death Spiral

The colossal meltdown of D.C. Metro was readers’ choice for biggest local failure of 2016. Despite a booming local economy and high-profile recent expansions, Metro has managed to actually shed passengers in the last 10 years. After a string of dangerous smoke and fire incidents, one of which proved fatal, the feds stepped in this year to assume safety oversight from WMATA — and at one point instituted an emergency closure that shuttered all rail service in the middle of the week. Now, facing a major budget shortfall, Metro is weighing a combination of service cuts and fare hikes, a recipe for another ridership decline that may necessitate more cuts.

Worst Victim Blaming: Kalamazoo Helmet Lecture

Even in the most egregious cases of driver recklessness, local reporters struggle to contain their impulse to blame the victims of fatal traffic crashes. This June, an intoxicated motorist ran over and killed five cyclists in Kalamazoo, Michigan. The victims were out for a training ride and were all wearing helmets. The man who hit them and fled the scene was reportedly high on pain pills and muscle relaxers.

Still, a Grand Rapids newscaster thought of this crash as a great opportunity to remind cyclists to “practice bike safety,” and reporter Sarah Sell’s tips included wearing a helmet.

Worst Trend: Rising Road Carnage

2016 was an especially gory year on American roads, especially for bicyclists and pedestrians. Graph: NHTSA
The trend in traffic deaths is moving in the wrong direction. Graph: NHTSA

Bucking a long-term decline, traffic deaths are now on the rise in the United States. In 2015, the nation saw the biggest increase in traffic fatalities in 50 years, and the trend accelerated in the first six months of 2016. The increase is even more pronounced among pedestrians and cyclists.

Cheap gas and a growing economy have led to more driving mileage, and that surely explains part of the increase, but not all of it. Other factors have been debated, but there’s a growing consensus that in-car distractions like mobile devices and complex dashboard displays are also playing a role.

Heroes of 2016

Atlanta Beltline visionary Ryan Gravel took a bold stand when he abruptly resigned from the board of the organization charged with raising money for a ring of parks, trails, and transit around the city of Atlanta. Gravel said his resignation was necessary to highlight the rising rents resulting from the project and advocate for more robust solutions for people at risk of being displaced.

The organizers of the "Untokening" conference in Atlanta, for safe streets advocates of color.
The organizers of the “Untokening” conference in Atlanta. Photo: Argenis Apolinario

The organizers of the “Untokening” — Zahra Alabanza, Carolyn Szczepanski, Adonia Lugo, Naomi Doerner, Anthony Taylor, and Sahra Sulaiman — convened a national gathering in Atlanta this fall to elevate the voices people of color, who have been marginalized for too long in the safe streets movement.

This was the year that Houston’s top-to-bottom bus network redesign proved that it’s working, with bus ridership rising more than 3 percent in the 10 months since September 2015 while bus ridership declined in other Texas cities. The redesign would not have happened without local bus rider, blogger, and agitator Christof Spieler, who was appointed to Houston Metro’s board in 2010. The Houston bus network overhaul is now inspiring cities around the country, from Columbus to Denver, to do the same.

Villains of 2016

Chris Christie Photo: Gage Skidmore via Flickr
Chris Christie. Photo: Gage Skidmore via Flickr

This was the year that reality caught up to the hype of Uber‘s self-driving car initiative. After an Uber self-driving car got caught running a red light through a crosswalk in San Francisco, the company admitted the cars can’t handle some common urban traffic situations very well. Nevertheless, when California regulators tried to pull the plug on Uber’s pilot, the company blatantly flouted the law before finally capitulating a few days later.

Forget about Bridgegate. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie’s biggest transportation scandal is that he ran New Jersey transit into the ground and produced a transportation funding crisis so severe, construction work had to be temporarily halted across the state.

After trading in anti-semitism and misogyny at Breitbart, Steve Bannon took his propaganda skills to the Trump campaign and parlayed that gig into a frighteningly influential White House advisor position. Bannon landed on this list because he claims to be a big behind-the-scenes booster of Trump’s infrastructure plan. He told the Hollywood Reporter that he’s pushing infrastructure spending as part of his “economic nationalist” agenda, but demonstrated complete cluelessness about the present-day infrastructure needs.

  • Glenn Scott

    Keep up the good work Angie and the best to you in the New Year!

  • ecycled

    I must second the gratitude for all the great writing you’ve provided us all here on Streetsblog. Thanks!

  • As a DC transit advocate, while I certainly agree it’s been a rough year for WMATA and its Streetsie is well-deserved, this is incorrect:

    “After a string of dangerous smoke and fire incidents, one of which proved fatal, the feds stepped in this year to assume safety oversight from WMATA — and at one point instituted an emergency closure that shuttered all rail service in the middle of the week.”

    The feds stepped in for more oversight, and WMATA did institute a 1-day emergency closure, but it was the new General Manager Paul Wiedefeld, not the feds, who initiated it.

    Also, while it’s a good year to recognize Metro’s decline, arguably, it’s been this bad for a looooong time; the system just finally has a General Manager who’s willing to rip off the band-aid and admit how bad things are.

  • Great article! I would love to see these topics expanded a bit more out of big cities. What are the wins and pains for the nation as a whole and not simply major cities?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Transit Vote 2016: Atlanta May Finally Expand MARTA and Beef Up Bus Service

|
We continue our overview of what’s at stake in the big transit ballot initiatives this November with a look at Atlanta. Previous installments in this series examined Indianapolis, Seattle, and Detroit. Back in the 1970s, both Atlanta and Washington, D.C., received federal grants to build rail networks. After finishing the first wave of Metro construction, D.C. continued to invest, […]

Houstonians See Folly of Debt-Financed Sprawl, Even If Leaders Don’t

|
Voters in Montgomery County, Texas, rejected a road-building bond referendum. Despite local support for transit, county leaders plan to give the referendum another try. The Houston Chronicle reports that opposition to a $350 million bond measure, all of it for road construction, was led by residents of one affluent enclave who don’t want a traffic-inducing parkway extension. But there’s […]

Local Ballot Results: The Good, the Bad, and the Highway Money Grabs

|
While last night’s election is looking like decisively bad news for transit in the Senate and in several statehouses, the results from local ballot initiatives are a little brighter. Here are the highlights that have Streetsblog Network members buzzing, as well as results from other referendums around the country. Seattle Seattle voters approved a ballot […]

Transit Investments and the Failure of Randal O’Toole’s Short-Term Thinking

|
The Los Angeles Times recently ran a big story to the effect that the region’s major investments in transit are not paying off, since ridership has recently declined. But there are a lot of problems with the paper’s analysis, which Streetsblog LA looked at last week. Jarrett Walker at Human Transit has also taken issue with how the LA Times published sweeping conclusions about long-term […]