The Coming Infrastructure Crisis in Texas

The way Texas throws around money for highways — $5.2 billion for a third outer-belt for Houston, $2 billion for Dallas’ eighth downtown highway — you would think TxDOT was running over with cheddar. This is a state, need we remind you, that “found” $350 million for a stalled highway project local leaders freely admit was designed to encourage sprawl, not solve any pressing mobility problems.

A Texas-sized pothole in Dallas. Photo: ##http://dfw.cbslocal.com/2011/02/09/weather-delaying-txdot-pothole-repair/## CBS DFW##

But the Lone Star State is on a crash course toward a big infrastructure crisis, according to a new report from TRIP [PDF], a think tank supported by road builders, insurance agencies and other interest groups.

In 2010, the group reported, 18 percent of Texas’ urban roads were in “poor” condition — in need of replacement — and 27 percent were in “mediocre” condition — in need of resurfacing. Three percent of the state’s bridges were “structurally deficient” and another 15 percent were “functionally obsolete.”

The group estimates that road conditions contribute to one-third of all traffic fatalities and serious injuries. In addition, poor road conditions cost the average Texas driver $400 annually in repair costs, or $6.1 billion statewide, annually. And the toll is worse in metropolitan areas, according to the group.

“Because maintenance is just not sexy with the voters, public officials have decided to spend that money on expansions and new facilities, new capacity,” said David Crossley, of the smart growth think tank Houston Tomorrow. “TxDOT, while complaining it doesn’t have enough for proper maintenance of the existing system, has nevertheless embarked in earnest on the social engineering project that is SH99, euphemistically called ‘The Grand Parkway,’ which is intended to open up new land for sprawl development at the very edges of the region. That’s a $6 billion project.”

Texas itself has estimated that $9.9 billion is needed annually just to maintain the state’s current road network and “keep congestion at 2012 levels.” But the state will have just $2.6 billion to spend annually following 2013, according to TRIP.

“Texas faces a significant funding shortfall in the amount needed just to maintain the  transportation system in its current condition, let alone make needed expansions or undertake six new projects,” study authors wrote. “Unless transportation funding is increased at the local, state and federal level, Texas’ roads and bridges will become increasingly deteriorated and congested.”

Texas’ approach to its funding shortage seems to be business as usual, with a side of tolls. Which seems like a less than ideal strategy in a state where the population is expected to grow by 45 percent by 2030.

Maybe Texas could start by not spending tax money to build new highways for private companies and not putting monied interests in charge of the highway planning process.

Crossley has another suggestion: “a serious regional transit system.” The board of Houston’s transit agency, Metro, has been handing over one-quarter of its revenues for the past 35 years to road projects. That amounts to about $2.7 billion transferred from transit to roads. And what does Texas have to show for it? Potholed and congested roads and an ever-shrinking pot of money to fix them.

  • Very eye-opening piece here! As mentioned, maintenance is usually trumped by new construction. However, to turn the tide of neglect comes down to attention. Highway and local road motorists must be vigilant and begin reporting potholes, bridge disrepair, and other items at targeted, location-specific emphasis. Such data-driven everyday user and stakeholder input will illustrate this alarming situation among policymakers and public managers.

  • Rapierlynx

    This reminds me of the First Rule of Holes: when you’re in one, stop digging.

    It also seems to support Strong Towns’ assertion that sprawl is a Ponzi scheme.

  • Chester T

    First, from a Texan, a little perspective.  TxDOT is responsible for
    state right of way (ROW) only.  Which is only about 27% of the state total of 300,000 miles of roadway (http://www.window.state.tx.us/specialrpt/tif/transportation.html).  Furthermore, they are the logical organizer for large
    transportation projects where the entire resources of the state can be
    marshaled.

    Second, many of the urban roads are owned and managed
    by local entities (counties, cities, special transportation districts,
    etc.) so it isn’t TxDOT’s responsibility that they’re not maintained
    properly.

    Third, compare Texas’ bridge conditions to almost all
    other states and we’re in better shape.  Compare that to OH w/ about 20%
    structural deficiency (http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/bridge/deficient.cfm).

    Fourth,
    Texas has been leading the nation in job growth for years.  One of the
    reasons is population growth.  Folks need to live somewhere, they need
    to get to work, and goods need to travel for a vibrant economy.  That
    takes new, and yes, properly maintain existing roads where appropriate.

    Lastly,
    if you want to be taken seriously, present all the facts in as
    dispassionate manner as possible.  Otherwise you’re just not very
    believable.

  • Jardinero1

    I notice you take a weak swing at tolls as a funding mechanism when they are the best way to both fund and maintain highways.  Only the actual users of a toll road pay for their use and maintenance, no one is coerced into paying for a tollway they have no intention of using.  

  • Dianna9490

    What I don’t understand: if suggest is already congested THEN WHY KEEP KETTING DEVELOPERS DEVELOP ALL THESE STEPFORD WIVES STYLE SUBDIVISIONS?

  • Dianna9490

    Toll ways r not the answer! JUST LOOK AT DALLAS!!!! HELLO! Stopping all the STEPFORD WICES STYLE SUBDIVISIONS ARE!!!!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Texas DOT Seems Open to a Downtown Dallas Highway Removal

|
Will Texas embrace a model of mobility that works well for cities, instead of tearing them up with wider highways? A new report from the Texas Department of Transportation indicates that at least in some circumstances, the answer may be “Yes.” TxDOT last week released its “CityMAP” plan for urban highways in central Dallas [PDF]. Normally, you […]

A Road Block for Texas DOT’s Highway Robbery Plan?

|
The Texas Department of Transportation loves big highway projects. In fact, right now, it’s pursuing a third outerbelt for Houston that makes the moon landing seem like a minor undertaking. It’s the black blotch that can’t even fit into the above infographic comparing the sizes of global ring roads. As a result of all this, […]

The Fiscal Insanity of Highway Building

|
To peer inside the minds of highway builders, take a look at what’s happening in Dallas. Patrick Kennedy at Network blog Walkable Dallas Fort Worth has been poring over a 2007 document produced by regional planners at the North Central Texas Council of Governments. Interestingly, this seven-year-old document proclaimed an urgent need for the as-yet-unbuilt Trinity Toll […]

Texas DOT Raring to Build Money-Losing Toll Lanes

|
States seem to love expanding highways by adding tolled lanes, even when the money doesn’t add up. The 495 Express Lanes in DC’s Virginia suburbs lost $51 million last year, forcing investors to restructure $430 million in debt. Similarly, Maryland taxpayers are likely to be on the hook for the state’s new I-95 lanes, which […]