APHA Tallies ‘Hidden Health Costs’ of Transportation Status Quo

The nation’s transportation planning process fails to account for more
than $200 billion per year in "hidden health costs" imposed by traffic and air
pollution, according to a new report from the American Public Health
Association (APHA) that maps the nexus between infrastructure and
health care.

08congestion_600.jpgTraffic brings with it billions of dollars in "hidden health costs," according to the APTA. (Photo: NYT)

The APHA’s report (available for download here) echoes many of the policy recommendations issued by the Centers for Disease Control last month: stronger incentives to expand bicycle and pedestrian networks, as well as more frequent measurement of the health impacts of new transport projects.

But the APHA, a trade association representing public health workers, went further than the government by adding up the estimated costs imposed by the absence of any mandatory evaluation of the health consequences of transportation decisions.

Citing U.S. DOT and American Automobile Association studies, respectively, the APHA pegged the annual price of congested roads at between $50 billion and $80 billion, with the health toll of traffic crashes — including the treatment of fatalities, the resulting court costs, and lost wages — reaching $180 billion per year.

The majority of those bills are paid indirectly by the transportation system users they affect, not factored in advance into local planning, as the APHA writes:

The federal government does not require a consistent methodology for environmental impact analysis, transportation modeling, or cost-benefit analysis for agencies seeking federal highway funding — and while this approach allows agencies to tailor analyses to fit their needs, itmakes it impossible to compare potential project effectiveness at a national level. It also  means that health impacts, costs and benefits are often left off the table when projects are being considered.

What can be done to build those health risks into the calculus that determines where roads get built, bridges fixed, and crosswalks painted? The APHA offers San Francisco, where health officials used economic modeling to weigh the likely pedestrian injury rates caused by five alternative development plans, as an example of effective local analysis of transportation’s effect on public health.

But the APHA report underscores the difficulty of achieving a broader shift without Congress requiring a stronger emphasis on transport policies that tangibly improve Americans’ health. In addition to endorsing the concept of national transportation objectives — which has won some Democratic support but sparked resistance from state DOTs — the group’s new report urges that those new federal standards "allocate more funds to projects and efforts that support healthy communities and active transportation."

  • Congestion is one of the easier costs to estimate. What would be more interesting is quantifying pollution costs, for which the current estimates have a very wide range.

  • Kevin Love

    Toronto’s Medical Officer of Health, Dr. David McKeown, produced a report quantifying the effects of car pollution in Toronto. Car pollution in Toronto:

    *Kills 440 people every year.
    *Injures 1,700 people every year so seriously they require hospitalisation.
    *Imposes mortality costs of $2.2 billion every year.

    The report may be found at:

    http://www.toronto.ca/health/hphe/pdf/air_pollution_burden.pdf

  • gecko

    Providing the link with health care this report directly addresses the structural violence of transportation systems based on cars just as Dr. Paul Farmer did years ago directly for health care.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Auto Industry Wants Your Thanks

|
Feeling warmer and fuzzier about the auto industry bailout? With the help of the Obama reelection campaign, the industry is convincing more Americans that the $80 billion they forked over to save it were dollars well spent. In the latest Pew poll, the public responded more positively toward the bailout than ever before, with 56 […]

Think Tank Responds to Report on Hidden Costs of Fossil Fuels: Yawn

|
The National Academy of Science’s new report on the hidden health costs of U.S. reliance on fossil fuels has generated high-profile media coverage around the country, most of it focusing on the $62 billion annual estimate for coal rather than the $56 billion projection for vehicles. (Photo: SILive.com) But Greenwire’s write-up is particularly interesting, if […]

APTA Report Prescribes Public Transport to Improve Public Health

|
Transit use is correlated with decreases in the number of traffic crashes. Image: "Evaluating Public Transportation Health Benefits" A new report written by the Victoria Transport Policy Institute’s Todd Litman for the American Public Transit Association [PDF], the trade organization for the nation’s transit agencies, reminds us that one of the most valuable benefits of […]

New Study Shows $56 Billion in Hidden Health Damage from Autos

|
Transportation’s effects on public health are rarely discussed by policy-makers, but they remain very real — and the National Research Council (NRC) put a number on them today, reporting that cars and trucks have about $56 billion in "hidden" health costs that are not reflected in the price of oil or electricity. (Photo: MetroDCLiving.com) In […]

Livable Streets Are Good for Health in the Heartland, Too

|
The roadscape in Nebraska, built for one thing only. Photo by jWiltshire via Flickr. The health benefits of livable streets don’t always get enough attention. Today on the Streetsblog Network, we’ve got a story from Missouri Bicycle News about a new study from the St. Louis University School of Public Health documenting how the health […]

Measuring the Global Health Impact of Transportation Reform

|
The relationship between active transportation and public health can seem so plainly obvious that we tend to take it for granted. Who could question that air pollution, obesity, and road fatalities are major public health concerns that have a direct connection to the availability of safe and convenient travel options other than driving? But as […]