What Explains the Decline in Driving Among Young People?

Young people continue to shift to sprawling new suburban development more than cities. Graph: UCLA
Young people continue to shift to sprawling new suburban development more than cities. Graph: UCLA

Young adults today drive less than previous generations did at the same age — that much is clear. The question is why.

The cause of the shift is a subject of dispute. Graduated driver’s licenses, changing attitudes among young people, economic contraction, and the rise of mobile communications have all been floated as explanations.

A pair of new studies by researchers at UCLA seeks to provide some answers [PDF, PDF]. Here’s what they found.

Rising youth unemployment is a big factor

Using data from the 2001 and 2009 National Household Travel Survey, Evelyn Blumenberg and her colleagues at UCLA found that people age 15 to 26 drove about 18 percent fewer miles than previous age cohorts at the same stage of life. But the researchers concluded that this shift was primarily a reflection of rising unemployment.

The employment rate for this age group fell from 70 percent in 2001 to 56 percent in 2009. During this time the share of carless young people rose from about 9 percent to about 15 percent. The increase in carlessness was concentrated among young people in the bottom 40 percent of the income scale.

The biggest declines in driving came from poorer youth who lost their cars during the recession, although there was a smaller increase in carlessness and multi-modal behavior at the higher end of the income spectrum as well.
The biggest declines in driving came from poorer youth who lost their cars during the recession, although there was a smaller increase in carlessness and multi-modal behavior at the higher end of the income spectrum as well.

While there was some degree of mode shift to transit and biking independent of changes in employment, the research team says this effect was much smaller than the decline in driving due to economic factors. “We see a situation where people are really not traveling much by other means, they’re really not traveling as much at all,” co-author Brian Taylor explained in a webinar hosted by the Eno Center for Transportation.

For many young people, transit isn’t really an option

While there is evidence that young people prefer urban environments, the fact remains that there aren’t that many walkable urban places in the U.S.

Only about 4 percent of U.S. neighborhoods are considered “old urban” — dense, walkable, with good transit options. Half of those neighborhoods are in the New York City region, and 90 percent are in the nation’s five largest metro areas.

So the parts of the country that are capturing a bigger share of the population between age 20 and 36 remain sprawling new suburban development (see top chart).

As Taylor put it in his presentation, “The places where we’re seeing the most driving still are the places that are growing the fastest, even with some of the urban revitalization that we’re seeing around the country.”

A big shift in travel behavior won’t happen without big shifts in policy

Barring major changes in transportation policy or land use patterns, significant declines in driving are not likely to be sustained.

“We cannot see any evidence in our work that some demographic deus ex machina will come in and save the day,” said Taylor.

Changing travel behavior still boils down to good old policy reform — restructuring incentives to favor modes of travel other than solo driving, creating better access to transit and safe walking and biking, and allowing more housing and development in urban places.

  • war_on_hugs

    Interesting findings. I’ll have to read the full story, but offhand, I wonder if the unemployment/less driving correlation could be also be related to shifting attitudes – many teenagers take a job specifically so that they can afford a car, gas, etc. If they don’t care (as much) about a car, there’s less need for a job. The fact that way fewer teens even get drivers’ licences these days also points to the idea that there’s more going on.

  • Steep Ravine

    Walk, bicycle, skateboard, skate…non-motorized scooter etc = lots more fun, good for your body and soul, better for the planet. Making a conscious decision to opt out of the fossil fuel con job is wise!

  • zentierra

    I completely concur! I donated my car in October 2015, and have never regretted it. I have a monthly transit pass, and bought a nice (worth the investment) bicycle. Not being enslaved to a car payment etc.. has allowed me to cut back work to four days a week (which means more time to, you know, actually *enjoy* life). Also, that one move to go car-free began a general downsizing and slow-living mindset that has -in addition to the aforementioned cut in work hours- caused me to shed almost 38 lbs, without dieting. I attribute that *directly* to the benefits of walking, rding a bike, and the cut in stress, which has also organically changed my eating habits. So far car-free has been a win/win for me 🙂

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Goodbye, James Dean: Young Men Reject America’s Car Obsession

|
Phineas Baxandall is a senior analyst at the U.S. Public Interest Research Group. This piece was originally posted on Huffington Post. Just released official data show that Americans drove a billion fewer miles in April 2012 compared to April 2011, despite a slightly better economy. It’s now well known that Americans, led by youth, have been reducing their […]

More Evidence That Unemployment Doesn’t Explain the Decline in Driving

|
For those who say driving rates will pick right back up again when the economy’s really humming, here’s something to chew on: In a report released this morning, “Moving Off the Road,” U.S. PIRG presents further evidence that unemployment rates and driving rates have changed independently of each other. Transportation reformers have made the case that there […]

U.S. PIRG Report: Young Americans Dump Cars for Bikes, Buses

|
The U.S. Public Interest Research Group has been crunching the numbers on travel preferences among young Americans — and the news is not good for auto makers. The report — Transportation and the New Generation — is chock-full of nuggets like this: Driving is down: “From 2001 to 2009, the annual number of vehicle miles […]

Where Is the Bottom? Americans Continue to Drive Less and Less

|
The downward slide continues. Driving activity in America, adjusted for population, has hit a new low since before the economic downturn began. Doug Short, an independent analyst who evaluated data recently released by FHWA, finds that when controlling for population growth, it’s been more than seven years, or 92 months, since American driving activity last […]