Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Detroit

Transit Vote 2016: With Historic Decision, Detroit Could Heal Old Divides

1:51 PM EDT on October 19, 2016

The highlight of metro Detroit's $4.6 billion transit plan is four bus rapid transit routes connecting the city to suburban job centers. Map: Michigan RTA. Click to enlarge.
The highlight of metro Detroit's $4.6 billion transit plan is four bus rapid transit routes connecting the city to suburban job centers. Map: Michigan RTA. Click to enlarge.
The highlight of metro Detroit's $4.6 billion transit plan was four bus rapid transit routes connecting the city to suburban job centers. Map: Michigan RTA. Click to enlarge.

We continue our overview of what’s at stake in the big transit ballot initiatives this November with a look at Detroit. Previous installments in this series examined Indianapolis and Seattle

The four-county transit ballot measure before voters in Southeast Michigan this November is truly historic.

It took 40 years and 23 failed attempts for Detroit and its suburbs to establish a regional transit agency. They finally won state support to establish the RTA in 2012. At the time, Detroit was on the verge of bankruptcy, and its general-revenue-supported transit system was in dire condition.

Transit service in the region is fragmented and unreliable, even though a quarter of city residents don't own cars. The severity of the problem was encapsulated by the story of James Robertson, whose commute to a factory job in the suburbs required taking two buses and walking 21 miles.

The Detroit region is the largest U.S. metro area without a unified regional transit system. This photo shows a suburban "Smart" bus. Photo: Michigan RTA
The Detroit region is the largest U.S. metro area without a unified transit system. This photo shows a suburban "Smart" bus. Photo: Michigan RTA
Photo: Michigan RTA

The RTA can't deliver a better transit system without funding, and that's where the vote in November comes into play.

The Detroit region has put together a $4.6 billion, four-county plan to improve transit. The centerpiece is a network of bus rapid transit lines extending out from downtown. Funded by a 20-year property tax increase, the measure would cost the average homeowner in the region about $95 a year.

Megan Owens, director of the advocacy group Transit Riders United, says the measure is important for a few reasons. Right now, urban and suburban transit services are poorly integrated. That's what messed up James Robertson's commute -- the suburb he worked in opted out of the suburban transit system. The lack of coherent transit connections makes the region's notorious job sprawl an even bigger problem.

Thousands of people in the region have to go to extraordinary lengths just to get to work, Owens said. "There’s some huge gaps," she said. "There’s a lot of places that you can’t get to or that people are forced to ride two and three hours just to get where they need to get."

Detroit has some of the lowest per-capita transit spending of any major U.S. metro. Graph: Michigan RTA
In the Detroit region, per capita spending on transit is truly abysmal. Graph: Michigan RTA
Detroit has some of the lowest per-capita transit spending of any major U.S. metro. Graph: Michigan RTA

The measure enjoys broad support as a means of both improving job access for low-income residents and attracting and retaining educated young people. The Detroit Regional Chamber of Commerce backs the transit initiative, one of 300 groups in a coalition that includes a range of interests, from environmental groups and disability advocates to Ford Motor Company.

The backbone of the system will be four bus rapid transit lines connecting Detroit to major employment centers, reaching as far as Pontiac and Ann Arbor. The plan also calls for "regional rail" between Ann Arbor and downtown Detroit. Other service expansions include a network of "cross-county connectors" running between suburbs and "commuter express" lines on some of the region's major highways.

When complete, the new system will put nearly a million jobs and more than a million residents within a quarter mile of transit.

Some opposition emerged from the northern suburbs, but key political actors who could have blocked it, like Oakland County Executive Brooks Patterson (the "Sprawl King") have opted not to.

It seems that the Detroit region has finally unified around the need for better transit.

"We’ve had some pretty rough history of racial tension and division between the city and the suburbs," said Owens. "Some of the things that other regions take for granted as obvious to the importance of a vibrant central city is sort of a novel concept for some people in Southeast Michigan."

Now, attitudes are changing.

"Enough people have visited every other metro region and realized, 'Hey maybe we are missing out on something here,'" she said.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Monday’s Headlines Drink Your Milkshake

How does a president end wasteful subsidies for the highly profitable fossil fuel industry? Many have tried, but none have succeeded, including Joe Biden.

March 18, 2024

How — and Why — To Start a Neighborhood E-Bike Library

American advocates are loaning out e-bikes to their neighbors — and creating flocks of new riders.

March 18, 2024

What Urbanists’ Doug Burgum Lovefest Reveals About the ‘Why’ Behind Our Advocacy

I am far less interested in talking about Gov. Doug Burgum's politics than talking about his values, and how those values shape his urbanism, and thus the actual lives of the people he governs.

March 15, 2024

‘Transit Hardship’: Report Shows Why Fair Fares Must Be Expanded to More Workers

A new report on transit fares has found that more than one-in-five moderate-income residents is “affordability hardship.”

March 15, 2024

Friday’s Headlines, Land Ho!

Transit agencies own a bunch of land, and some say they should sell it for housing to create more ridership.

March 15, 2024
See all posts