It’s Not Good Transit If the Streets Nearby Aren’t Good for Walking

All transit stops aren’t created equal. The street environment around the station — especially safe, convenient pedestrian access — has a major influence on how people use transit.

A wide road with strip malls on the way to a transit stop in San Diego. Photo: Edward Russell/GGW

Edward Russell at Greater Greater Washington compares two stops that offer very different walking environments — one in San Diego and one in Washington:

The 1.1-mile walk from the Grossmont Trolley station in the San Diego suburb of La Mesa to my family’s house takes you through a strip mall parking lot, along the six-lane major arterial Fletcher Parkway and then up the overly wide four-lane Jackson Drive before you turn into their neighborhood. It’s not pleasant, as the picture above shows.

As a result, my family only drives to the station when they ride the Trolley, and I — someone who likes to ride transit — think twice about making the walk when I’m there.

The crazy thing is that this is a comparable distance to what I walk a couple of times a week from the Shaw-Howard U Metro station to my house in Eckington.

What’s the difference? The walk in DC is along leafy streets lined with rowhouses in the Le Droit Park and Bloomingdale neighborhoods. Yes, I cross three major roads — Florida Avenue, and North Capitol Street and Rhode Island Avenue where they meet — but it is just two intersections, and I do not walk along either street for very long.

The Grossmont stop, Russell says, is “a reminder that simply building transit is not all that it takes to make a suburban neighborhood walkable and generate new transit ridership.” What suburbs like La Mesa need to do is rethink not only street design but also car-centric development patterns near transit stations.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Project for Public Spaces reports on a community-based initiative in St. Paul to reconnect neighborhoods that have been disrupted by an old urban freeway. Bike PGH explains how the “Dutch Reach” can help drivers and car passengers avoid dooring cyclists. And The Urbanist says that Seattle is considering ways to fast-track infill development.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Trading a Park-and-Ride for a Public Plaza and Bike Parking

|
More cities should copy this idea for their park-and-ride transit stations: At DC Metro’s King Street station in Old Town Alexandria, plans are underway to turn parking spots into a pedestrian plaza. This goes against the grain of typical transit agency practice. Despite the fact that park-and-rides are an inefficient use of scarce land, a recent survey by researchers […]

Vote to Decide the Best Urban Street Transformation of 2014

|
If you’re searching for reasons to feel positive about the future, the street transformations pictured below are a good start. Earlier this month we asked readers to send in their nominations for the best American street redesigns of 2014. These five are the finalists selected by Streetsblog staff. They include new car-free zones, substantial sidewalk […]

What Will It Take to Make Las Vegas Walkable?

|
Saying the future of the city’s economy depends on it, Las Vegas tourism interests are pushing a $12 billion plan to improve transit and walkability, reports the Associated Press. A group of tourism industry leaders, hotel owners, transit officials, and taxi companies are backing a plan from the Regional Transportation Commission of Southern Nevada that includes major transit expansions and street overhauls, as […]