Philly’s Railcar Meltdown and America’s Disastrous Train Regulations

Philadelphia’s commuter rail system has been plunged into turmoil after transit officials discovered a defect in SEPTA railcars this weekend.

Hyundai's Silverliner V train cars debuted in 2010. Photo: Plan Philly
SEPTA’s Silverliner V railcars had to be built to specs outside international norms. Photo: Plan Philly

All 120 railcars delivered just three years ago by Hyundai Rotem, an American subsidiary of the Hyundai Motor Group, have cracks in load-bearing components. SEPTA officials say caution requires them to remove the cars from service for repairs.

That means 30 percent of the regional rail system’s rolling stock is out of commission, and SEPTA doesn’t have many trains to spare, reports the Philly Inquirer. Crowding, delays, and a general diminishment in service are expected to last through the summer as the agency works with the supplier to correct the problem.

In the interim, SEPTA may try to borrow cars from NJTransit or Amtrak, according to local news sources. But major disruptions seem unavoidable. The Delaware Valley Association of Rail Passengers is advising its 400 members to look into flextime or telecommuting.

“I guess I’ll start driving,” one rider told the local NBC affiliate after waiting an hour for a train. “It’s too much.”

Hyundai Rotem’s Silverliner V model was supposed to be SEPTA’s “most advanced” railcar. Even before this critical defect, however, there was a long delay in delivering the cars.

The supplier is taking heat for shoddy workmanship. But SEPTA’s railcar troubles are also linked to two key sets of federal regulations.

Federal Railroad Administration safety rules

Federal rail safety regulations require transit agencies to purchase railcars built to withstand enormous forces in the event of a collision without deformation. These rules make U.S. trains much heavier than Asian or European models and often necessitate custom designs.

Matt Mitchell of the Delaware Valley Association of Rail Passengers suggested to the Inquirer that these customizations may have played a role in the Silverliner V defects. But Mitchell told Streetsblog that without a detailed engineering study it’s too early to reach conclusions.

Even if this particular defect does not stem directly from any FRA regulation, however, the agency’s safety rules greatly complicate the process of procuring railcars, which introduces uncertainty and risk. Hyundai, for example, had never constructed stainless steel railcars to FRA standards prior to this order. Other international suppliers have struggled to deliver railcars to FRA specs on time and on budget.

The FRA safety regulations are in line for revision, but anticipated updates have been delayed.

Buy America requirements

The FRA and Federal Transit Administration both require trains to be built with a certain percentage of components and materials manufactured in America. Silverliner V cars were built at a Philly factory by an American subcontractor to Hyundai Rotem. The specific defective component may have come from Columbus Castings, based in Ohio.

To comply with the Buy America rule and make its bid more attractive, Hyundai spent $25 million building a railcar factory in Philadelphia and flew many of the workers to Korea for training, according to McClatchy. The manufacturing process was plagued with problems, and the railcars weren’t delivered until 2013, almost three years late. “Material delays, design flaws, labor-management disputes, and workmanship problems delayed the delivery of the last of the cars,” reports the Inquirer.

Even after the Silverliner V cars were in service, they had problems with malfunctioning doors.

SEPTA wasn’t the only transit agency to purchase Silverliner V railcars — Denver’s RTD bought the same model. It’s not clear yet whether Denver’s trains suffer from the same defect.

  • Southern California is also having to deal with defective parts, in this case “pilots” (the plow or “cow-catcher” on the front of cab cars) with its Metrolink Commuter Rail service cars purchased from Hyundai-Rotem:

    http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-metrolink-parts-20160707-snap-story.html

  • Poisson Volant

    Denver’s version of the SL-V is similar but not identical. Most crucially, the cars are lighter than SEPTA’s and the equalizer bars are a somewhat different design. It’s also premature to compare the two systems’, uh, “track” records: SEPTA has been running their SL-Vs for about 3 years on a network that’s both larger and much older than Denver’s. RTD is just coming on line and its stress point – tracks, station configurations, etc. – are all brand new.

    Finally, SEPTA’s experience with Hyundai-Rotem may be extreme but it’s hardly unique. In addition to the issues that Erik Griswold noted in his post about southern Caliifornia, H-R has had problems in a number of other cities both in this country and in Europe.

  • j

    Was Denver’s deicision to buy FRA compliant trains something that was debated and viewed by some as uncecessary, as was the case with Marin’s commuter rail?

  • neroden

    It was actually quite difficult to avoid. For fairly dumb reasons. Denver’s system has to criss-cross Amtrak tracks to go in and out of service (avoiding this would require a massive gratuitous set of bridges). This subjects them to the FRA. 🙁

    The FRA needs to be fixed.

  • kclo3

    Everyone basically panicked after the Chatsworth collision, especially UP; even after establishing temporal separation and completely separate trackage with RTD they mandated the installation of concrete barriers, and consideration for LRT (and thus integration with the southern network) was immediately taken off the table. It’s especially troubling considering the Northeast-spec SLV they bought with 48-inch high platforms is totally incompatible with Amtrak or anything else in the West, and so the 3-something platform tracks they carved out for themselves at stub-end Union Station are going to be horribly congested when more rail lines open.

  • BillyPenn reported that RTD is pleased with their H-R cars.
    Via Planetizen:
    “Our engineers have been carefully inspecting [the rail cars] since we heard about what happened in Philadelphia,” said RTD spokesperson Nate Currey.
    “We have a slightly different model,” he continued, using an airline industry analogy. “It’s kind of like comparing a Boeing 737-500 to a 737-900er.”
    http://www.planetizen.com/node/87294/denvers-commuter-rail-cars-same-septas-without-defects
    From BillyPenn:
    “Why Denver’s Silverliner V cars still run, while SEPTA pulled Philly’s off the tracks,” by Danya Henninger, July 6, 2016

    “Currey added that — “with no disrespect to SEPTA” — he was under the impression that RTD’s stress testing had been “a little more thorough.”

    “From what I understand, Hyundai Rotem learned from Philly, and improved the process with us,” he said.

    Currey went on to praise manufacturer Hyundai Rotem, which assembled the cars in its South Philadelphia plant, for being open and communicative. “As soon as they identified the issue with SEPTA, they notified us right away.”……..
    http://billypenn.com/2016/07/06/why-denvers-silverliner-v-cars-still-run-while-septa-pulled-phillys-off-the-tracks/

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

When Will the Feds Stop Outlawing Railcars Used By the Rest of the World?

|
The removal of 115 railcars from service in Philadelphia last week was the latest example of the troubles American commuter rail agencies face when purchasing rolling stock. Thanks to cracks in a critical component of the railcars, riders are looking at severe service reductions for at least the entire summer. While U.S. DOT floated a regulatory change that could prevent similar […]

How Federal Rules Make It Harder to Build Trains in America

|
The Wall Street Journal‘s Bob Tita broke the news yesterday that the manufacturer of 130 new Amtrak railcars is years behind schedule, and probably won’t complete the order before the federal funding for it expires. How did this happen? The 130 double decker railcars were approved for purchase in the 2008 stimulus package, destined for service in the Midwest and California. But the terms […]

Will New Haven Replace a Highway With Highway-Like Conditions?

|
Around the Network today: Will Cars Dominate New Haven’s Post-Highway Development? Sustainability advocates cheered the city of New Haven’s plan to tear down a 1.1 mile stretch of highway near downtown, opening up space for a walkable mixed-use development on 10 acres of newly available land. The project was considered so innovative it was awarded […]

32 Rail Companies Commit to Expanding in U.S. Under High-Speed Rail Plan

|
As the Obama administration and Congress keep a close eye on jobless numbers and the shrinking American manufacturing base, Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said today that 32 rail companies that have promised to expand U.S. operations if they are chosen to help states build high-speed train networks. Transportation Secretary LaHood, at left, toured the Spanish […]

Buy America’s Shocking Pricetag

|
Within the big pro-transit tent, positions on Buy America policies — which compel agencies to purchase domestically-made materials — vary wildly. But from the perspective of providing more rail service to more people, these restrictions are unequivocally bad news. How bad? Network blog Systemic Failure recently looked at how the Federal Railroad Administration is about to spend […]