Why Are U.S. Transit Agencies Failing to Implement Modern Train Designs?

This map shows transit systems around the world. Those with open gangways are in green, those with closed individual train cars are in red. Click to enlarge. Map: Transport Politic
Transit systems with open gangways are in green, and systems without are in red. Click to enlarge. Map: Transport Politic

Almost every urban rail system in America lacks a key design feature that’s become standard in cities around the globe: open gangways, which let people easily walk between cars, increasing capacity and leading to smoother operations.

Yonah Freemark at the Transport Politic points out that even New York City’s extensive and crowded subway system won’t be including open gangways any time soon. He wonders when U.S. transit agencies are going to catch up to the rest of the world:

A train with open gangways designed for the London Underground. Image via Transport Politic

Open gangways provide a number of advantages: One, they expand capacity by allowing riders to use the space that typically sits empty between cars. This added capacity means that a metro line can carry more people with trains of the same length. Two, it allows passengers to redistribute themselves throughout the train while the vehicle is moving, reducing problems associated with many people boarding in the same doorway, such as slow exiting times and poorly distributed standees. Three, it increases safety at times of low ridership by increasing the number of “eyes” in the train. There are no obvious downsides.

Open gangways offer passengers the benefit of an improved, less congested, and safer environment as compared to trains with individual cars, the standard you’re used to if you live in the U.S. And it’s no surprise that transit agencies all around the world are choosing open-gangway trains for virtually every new vehicle purchase. This is documented in the following map, where green cities represent places where the metro systems run at least some trains that are all open-gangway. Those that are red do not.

Yet American transit agencies have ignored the concept. New metro trains have been or are being purchased in Chicago, New York, San Francisco, and Washington, among others, but they all continue to be built with individualized cars, with no open gangways. It’s as if the agencies simply have not gotten the message. Only Honolulu, which has a new purpose-built metro currently under construction, will adopt this technology. Perhaps the other agencies will get the message once that system opens in two years.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Systemic Failure says California’s youth helmet law doesn’t seem to have had an obvious impact on head injuries. BikeWalkLee reports that Florida’s three-foot passing law resulted in only eight convictions despite some 500 tickets issued last year. And Cap’n Transit shares his hypothesis about why so many Midwesterners relocate to New York City.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Today’s Headlines

|
Deferred Infrastructure Maintenance a Top Concern for Municipal Bond Analysts (Government Executive) Brookings Explains How States Have Been Filling Transportation Funding Gaps Despite Federal Inaction One of the Biggest Obstacles to Americans’ Retirement Is Spending Too Much on Cars (Globe and Mail) TRB Report: Land Use Impacts of Transit 4 Times More Important for Climate Than Actual […]

An Urgent Plea for Better Management at Washington Metro

|
Things are not looking up at the Washington Metro. Despite service expansions, strong regional population and economic growth, and a national increase in rail ridership, fewer and fewer people are riding Metro. Concerned about reliability and safety, riders are losing faith in Metro. Furthermore, Greater Greater Washington has pointed out that the agency’s finances are increasingly unsustainable. In light of these […]

How Transit Pays for the Automobile’s Sins

|
Tony Dutzik is a senior policy analyst with the Frontier Group. An op-ed in Friday’s Washington Post by three professors of urban planning rained on the parade of transit advocates celebrating a new 57-year high in transit ridership. Ridership, the authors wrote, has actually fallen on a per-capita basis since 2008 (as has driving, by the way), as well as outside […]

Today's Sign That America Is Falling Behind on Transport Policy

|
You know we’ve reached a low point in U.S. infrastructure policy when state officials are selling off public utilities in order to fund $1.7 billion highway interchanges. Contrast American gimmicks with the progress of some of our international competitors. Systemic Failure reports today that China is now operating four high-speed rail lines at a profit, […]