Citing Lack of Funds, Tennessee Calls Off $1.5 Billion Highway Project

Something tells me we’re going to be seeing a lot more of this in the not-so-distant future.

A rendering of I-69 through Tennessee. State officials have since halted construction due to lack of funds. Image: ##http://www.tdot.state.tn.us/i69/segment7/location4_3.htm## Tennessee DOT##

Last week Tennessee DOT commissioner John Schroer took to the pages of the Memphis Commercial Appeal to explain his decision to halt construction of his state’s portion of I-69. The reason, he explained, is that the state can’t afford the 65-mile, $1.5 billion highway project, between Memphis and Dyersburg.

“The $1.5 billion cost estimate represents more than 100 percent of Tennessee’s annual federal construction funding,” Schroer said. “To spend that on one project — regardless of its location — would not only be a disservice to all Tennesseans, but it would also be downright irresponsible and potentially dangerous. It would leave no money to repair and replace old bridges or implement safety improvements designed to save lives.”

In particular Schroer mentioned the unavailability of federal earmarks as a factor in the decision.

TDOT undertook an examination of its project pipeline last year with Smart Growth America and discovered that it had nine times more projects in its project list than available funding would cover. Determined to change the way it did business, Tennessee has been turning away from bypasses and road widening to concentrate more on integrating land use and transportation. The state wants to build places people want to go to and not just through at high speeds.

I-69 — also known as the NAFTA Superhighway — had received special designation from FHWA in 2007 as a “corridor of the future,” a distinction that was supposed to come with streamlined approval and federal funding. The mega highway was to connect Michigan and Canada to Texas and Mexico. The road has been touted as an economic development boon for the states it bisected.

Tennessee had spent close to two decades on planning, land acquisition and design work for I-69. The state had already spent $200 million, $150 million of which came from the federal government.

But Schroer expressed doubt other states would be able to complete their portions, given the current funding environment.

“Mississippi, Arkansas, Kentucky, Indiana and Texas are all facing tremendously expensive I-69 projects, including construction of bridges over the Mississippi and Ohio rivers,” he wrote.

Schroer said he would be happy to take up I-69 again “when long-term funding is identified.”

  • shane phillips

    That’s a surprisingly sober assessment for a state DOT to make. Kudos to Schroer for doing the right thing.

  • Adam Herstein

    Building a new interstate to connect Mexico with Canada would be superfluous – we already have a system of highways that do just that, albeit not all signed as a single numbered route. In addition, we also have an extensive freight rail system that can accomplish what I-69 is proposing.

  •  Was this roadway supposed to carry passenger autos or freight trucks?  For about the same amount of money we should be able to enhance the rails for freight or for high speed passenger service and we should get on with it.

  • At last, the highway/car/oil industrial complex is stopping. Now we can redirect money to other things.

  • Anonymous

    I’m glad the 69 isn’t getting built in Tennessee, because it’s a useless freeway. The 55 runs on the west side of the Mississippi in the same area, so the 69 was redundant. The whole 69 corridor is essentially served by I-35/I-30/I-40/I-55/I-57/I-70.

    But the “no money” argument is the wrong argument. The feds can borrow money at negative real rates. We ought to be using that ability to repair existing infrastructure and expand transit.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

House Lawmakers Hail Transportation Stimulus — But Add Three Caveats

|
At a House transportation committee hearing today that marked the one-year anniversary of the Obama administration’s economic recovery efforts, lawmakers offered praise for the stimulus law’s impact on local infrastructure investments even as they hit upon three key areas of concern with its implementation. The Port of Los Angeles was shut out of the stimulus’ […]

McClatchy Muckrakers Expose Seedy Underbelly of the Highway Bonanza

|
The work of a sustainable transportation reporter can be a lonely lot. But it’s a lot less lonely now that two McClatchy reporters, Curtis Tate and Greg Gordon, have taken up the mantle of exposing wasteful road expansion. With their far-reaching and well-researched three-part series, published last Sunday, Tate and Gordon brought stories of highway […]

Six States Seek Stimulus Aid to Add Rail to Congestion-Plagued I-81

|
Interstate 81 stretches for 846 miles through six states — New York, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, and Tennessee — and serves as a crucial corridor for freight traffic. But crucial doesn’t mean safe or enjoyable, and I-81 is an undisputed hotbed of traffic accidents. The safety and freight challenge that is I-81. (Photo: WaPo) […]

How State DOTs Waste Money Bailing Out Local Planning Mistakes

|
A few weeks ago, we featured a video of Tennessee Department of Transportation chief John Schroer describing the reforms he’s applying at his agency. One problem he pinpointed — and this happens to every state DOT — is when local governments ask his DOT to spend big sums of money fixing transportation problems that could have […]