How Salt Lake City Became a Leader in Transit-Oriented Development

In 2004, Salt Lake City faced a challenging question: How do you fit 1.4 million additional residents into a region hemmed in by mountains on the east and water on the west? In the course of solving that problem, the city ended up answering several other head-scratchers, like: How do you get buy-in for smart-growth policies from conservatives wary of urbanism? And, how do you make new greenfield development both sustainable and wildly popular?

In the Daybreak development southwest of Salt Lake City, streets were laid out in a connected network, and rates of walking and biking to school are sky-high. Image: ##http://www.daybreakutah.com/where/villages-map##Daybreak, Utah##

At the Rail~Volution conference last week, Andrew Gruber, executive director of the Wasatch Front Regional Council, showcased the transit-centered solution that’s now propelling development in Utah’s capital city.

If official projections are right, the high quality of life and thriving economy of the Wasatch Front could invite population growth of more than 65 percent by 2040.

If the region continued along current growth trends, Gruber explained, it would add more than 300 square miles of development to meet the housing and commercial demand by 2040. Vehicle miles traveled would nearly double, from 49 million to more than 90 million per day, by 2030. By 2020, the cost of new infrastructure could balloon to more than $26 billion.

In just a few decades, a region known for its open space and outdoor lifestyle would be a mighty congested and costly place to call home.

So, in 2004, the state’s two largest MPOs came up with a comprehensive plan for growth and development in the four-county region. “The Wasatch Choice for 2040” prioritizes housing and transportation choices — and earned a $5 million Sustainable Communities Planning Grant from HUD in 2010.

Now, Salt Lake City is investing more, per capita, in new public transit than any other metro area in the country, and exporting ideas to the rest of the country.

Starting in 2005, citizens and planners in the Wasatch Front evaluated different scenarios for growth, looking at the long-term consequences of each development pattern. Perhaps surprising for such a conservative state, the consensus that emerged included a set of progressive growth principles focused on efficient infrastructure, transportation and housing choice, and coordinated planning.

By following those guidelines, Wasatch Front residents could look forward to benefits like an 18 percent reduction in congestion (compared to the baseline projections).

The focus on town centers and TOD isn’t just a selling point for baby boomers and Gen Y professionals who are looking for walkable, urban neighborhoods. It also placates conservative Utahans, who don’t want the government encroaching on their lifestyles with newfangled sustainability mandates. “Not everybody wants to live in a town center. That’s fine,” Gruber said. “But if we can develop in a more concentrated way, with new homes and jobs in town centers, we’re preserving the character of existing neighborhoods, too.”

One model of this approach is the new Daybreak development, just southwest of Salt Lake City. “This community was planned with transportation choices in mind from the very beginning,” Gruber explained. A rail line extending from downtown has two stops in the mixed-use development. The community design prioritized sidewalks and walkability, organizing the streets in a connected grid that makes it easy to get from Point A to Point B without having to navigate a maddening maze of cul-de-sacs that seem to go in circles.

Those simple principles have had a dramatic impact on how residents get around the mixed-use neighborhoods. For instance, in Daybreak, an incredible 88 percent of kids walk or bike to school, compared to just 17 percent in other neighborhoods in the region.

And folks are lining up to live there. In 2010, the National Homebuilders Association named it Community of the Year, and this year, real estate consulting firm Robert Charles Lessor recognized the development as the 11th best-selling community in the country. “Daybreak is the most successful housing development in the region, and one of most successful in the country,” Gruber said. “It’s not that everybody wants to live in this type of development, but there’s a demand out there that’s not being met… This is a model for greenfield development done in smart, sustainable way.”

Salt Lake City officials have also coordinated housing and transit policies in the urban core, as well. In recent years, the region has made big investments in public transit. The per-capita investment in transit over the past 10 years is the highest of any region in the nation, according to Gruber. Since the first TRAX light rail line opened 10 years ago, three more lines have debuted, including two just last month, as well as a commuter rail line to the north. A commuter rail link to the south and a TRAX line to the airport are set to open in 2013.

The commuter and light rail systems meet at an intermodal hub on the west end of downtown Salt Lake City, in an area that the mayor described as a “derelict, downtrodden piece of our city.” The city is trying to change that by encouraging infill development near the transit hub, but for now, it poses some challenges.

“There’s a dead zone between the hub and the rest of downtown that’s impeding people’s desire to use the transit system,” Gruber said. “Right in that area, we’re doing a mix of uses — housing, commercial and retail — and using streetscaping to try to make this area a vibrant, vital area that people want to come to. So we’re using transportation as a catalyst to redevelop an under-developed area and enhance the use of the entire region’s transit network. This one project downtown benefits the entire region.”

The work in Salt Lake could also benefit cities around the country. As part of its HUD grant, the Wasatch Front Regional Council is using its experience to help other governments and citizens overcome two major barriers to sustainable development: lack of information and antiquated zoning requirements.

On the zoning front, the council is working on a form-based code that doesn’t splinter development into commercial areas and residential areas. “It focuses on the form of the building, instead,” Gruber said. “So, in a particular area you might want two- to three-story buildings with a certain set back from the streets, and whatever the market will bear is OK, as long as it fits the character of the neighborhood… That model will be available to folks across the country.”

Officials are also developing free, open-source technology that will help planners and empower advocates to make more informed choices about their communities’ development. The “Envision Tomorrow +” tool allows stakeholders to “paint in different scenarios” for growth and development, Gruber says, and see how it impacts important metrics like energy consumption, air quality, tax collections and return on investment. “It will allow more people to come to the table with good information and evaluate scenarios at the local level,” he said.

Art Guzzetti of the American Public Transportation Association praised Salt Lake’s progress. “What you’ve done in that region over the past decade,” he told Gruber, “is just extraordinary.”

  • Jake

    I agree that the Wasatch Front’s accomplishments with transit and land use are extraordinary. I would not, however, conclude from this that similar victories are close at hand in other conservative regions. Utah conservatism doesn’t look like Nevada conservatism or Georgia conservatism — it’s conservatism with more of an emphasis on community consensus and less on individual freedom. 

    Still, I’d love to see other regions imitate Utah. But there will be a lot of resistance. 

  • I am originally from Salt Lake but have been living in Seattle the past few years.  Recently returned to Salt Lake and pleasantly surprised with all the innovative changes to transporation and the revival of downtown.  Nice job Salt Lake! 

  • Anonymous

    Our non-commercial website is assembling first-person
    writings by Baby Boomers about their experiences. We are also developing a
    comprehensive timeline, the first installment of which – 1946 – is available
    for viewing. http://boomersrememberwhen.com/time-line/

    We’re looking for
    first hand, first person memories of growing up as a Boomer, coming of age, or
    how it has informed your adult life. It could be a magic moment listening to
    music. It could be your first job – or your last job. First car, first love,
    first house, first kid. If you hated being a Boomer, say it! What we’re trying
    to accomplish is to get a rounded, human picture of the enormous, often
    stereotyped generation. 

     

    Reading the ABOUT
    tab should make it a little clearer:

     

    http://boomersrememberwhen.com/what-were-about/

     
    We will publish your name as John D. or Mary
    S., not John Doe or Mary Smith.

    Thanks very much!

  • Lcta

    Much of the impetus for change is attributable to geography. Vancouver, Seattle, Portland, San Francisco all face similar geographical constraints. That said, Salt Lake is doing a great job with TRAX, commuter rail and their multi-modal hub. 

    The first time I walked from downtown to the Amtrak station, I didn’t feel all that safe. Last summer, it was really quite impressive how much change has taken place.

  • Anonymous

    Never forget that Utah is the “Beehive State” for a very good reason.

  • Billy Bob

    True Jake, but sooner or later congestion will reach such a point that the status quo will be be less unsustainable (a fuzzy future oriented kinda term) more INSUFFERABLE (as in a palpable pain in the ass RIGHT NOW). After all, L.A. was conservative once upon a time, as was Northern Virginia where I live.

    Every city will tackle this somewhat differently but the largest areas will soon consider a new type of urban zoning and planning when they realize that they can’t handle anymore traffic. And this is irregardless of the political bent of the public.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Salt Lake City, Rising Transit Star

|
On the roster of cities making progress on green transportation in the western U.S., you have the usual suspects like Portland and Denver. But in terms of building track miles and adding busways, the city on the fastest pace might just be Salt Lake City, Utah. Over the last decade, the capital of the reddest […]

Salt Lake City: A Red State Capital Builds Ambitious Transit

|
According to Congress for New Urbanism President John Norquist, the Salt Lake City area has the fastest growing rail system in America. And as Streetsblog’s Angie Schmitt pointed out last month, “It’s the only city in the country building light rail, bus rapid transit, streetcars and commuter rail at the same time.” Since the late 1990s, SLC […]

Without Transit, American Cities Would Take Up 37 Percent More Space

|
Even if you never set foot on a bus or a train, chances are transit is saving you time and money. The most obvious reason is that transit keeps cars off the road, but the full explanation is both less intuitive and more profound: Transit shrinks distances between destinations, putting everything within closer reach. A new study published by the Transportation Research Board quantifies […]

How Better Traffic Models Can Lead to More Mixed-Use Development

|
Here’s another obscure but significant obstacle to building walkable places in America: the Institute of Transportation Engineers’ shoddy traffic generation models for mixed-use development. The model used by traffic engineers around the country to measure “trip generation” at new developments consistently overestimates the amount of motor vehicle traffic produced by mixed-use projects, according to the […]

Parking Madness: Grand Rapids vs. Salt Lake City

|
The final spot in the “Elite Eight” of parking craters is riding on this match. Either Grand Rapids, Michigan, or Salt Lake City, Utah, will move on to the second round of Parking Madness, Streetsblog’s annual contest for eternal parking infamy. Both cities have their natural strengths. Grand Rapids, of course, is part of the […]