House Votes to Strip High-Speed Rail Funding

This morning, the House voted 232-182 for an Energy and Water Appropriations bill that redirects $1 billion of high-speed rail money to flood relief for the Midwest.

Of course midwestern flood victims need relief. Does it need to come at the expense of high-speed rail? Photo: ##

Never mind that that flood relief won’t arrive for many months, since this is a 2012 appropriations bill. The important thing here is to kill high-speed rail.

(Why? I dunno. ‘Cause the president likes it?)

The high-speed rail money is still in federal hands thanks to Florida Gov. Rick Scott’s decision to send it back — another thing to thank Scott for.

Democrat Louise Slaughter of New York said the choice between flood relief and high-speed rail was a false one. “The attempt to rescind this money is nothing but an opportunistic attempt to gain politically from a human tragedy,” she said in a speech on the floor of the House. “The flooding that has occurred in our nation’s heartland is being used as an excuse to eliminate an investment in our transportation network and our future.”

She says New York stands to lose big if the funds are rescinded — about $450 million is on the line.

However, if USDOT acts fast to release the money, it will no longer be sitting in federal coffers, open to rescission when the House bill takes effect. Immediately after passage of the House bill, New Jersey senators Frank Lautenberg and Robert Menendez, both Democrats, sent a letter to Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, asking him to expedite the release of $450 million in funding for Amtrak and NJ Transit improvements [PDF].

The House move is an assault on high-speed rail; no doubt. But it may not be a successful one. The Senate and White House are unlikely to go along with the cut, and given the gridlock in Congress over every spending bill that comes its way, a final vote on Appropriations is likely still a long way off.

  • Usbullettrain

    Mike Lehman
    New York & Chicago HSRPlease join this new HSR(bullet train) advocacy group on facebook: links belowAlso, please comment and forward links below to others, thank you….A NEW High Speed Rail-Bullet Train ADVOCACY GROUP:on facebook or google: New York & Chicago HSROR

  • Usbullettrain

    Mike Lehman
     New York & Chicago HSR

     Please join this new HSR(bullet train) advocacy group on facebook: links below

     Also, please comment and forward links below to others, thank you.
      A NEW High Speed Rail-Bullet Train ADVOCACY GROUP: on facebook or google: New York & Chicago HSR  OR email:

  • This is very wrong. If HSR is done right it will save millions of gallons of imported oil and millions of hours of lost travel time every month.
    HSR is the 21st Century Interstate Highway system. We could have done without the Interstate Highways including all f the destruction it did to many of our cities but it improved our quality of life considerably and the same is true for HSR. We can do without it, but the cost will be a much lower quality of life for many of us. Longer delays at airports and lower driving speeds, expensive airport and highway expansion and so much more. Let’s get a good HSR system into operation as much of the rest of the world has and stop steeling HSR money for other projects. What would happen if the funding for the Midwest floods were stolen from the DOD or the Highway rust fund?


NJ Rep. Frelinghuysen Goes After HSR Money Destined For His Own State

As towns flanking the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers continue to be inundated with historically high water, it’s good to see Congress taking action to provide some relief. Unfortunately, that relief comes on the back of high-speed rail programs. Last week, Rep. Rodney Frelinghuysen (R-NJ), who chairs the Energy and Water Appropriations Subcommittee, introduced an amendment […]

Senate Strips High-Speed Rail Funding

The Senate’s transportation budget proposal is still under wraps, but we’re getting some clues about what’s in it. This morning, a subcommittee marked up the transportation and HUD appropriations bill, and the full committee will consider it tomorrow afternoon. Only after that will the draft bill be released. During this morning’s subcommittee markup, though, a […]

LaHood, Biden Meet With Governors on High-Speed Rail

Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood and Vice President Biden met at the White House this afternoon with officials from 20 states in contention for funding as part of the Obama administration’s high-speed rail program. The high-speed Midwest Regional Rail Initiative’s proposed reach. (Photo: Michigan Messenger) "This is how the interstate highway system started, folks," Biden told […]

LaHood Defends High-Speed Rail Program At House Hearing

It’s Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood’s birthday, and he’s spending it testifying before the House Transportation Committee. The hearing is on “Mistakes & Lessons Learned” from the high-speed rail program, but — no surprise here — LaHood and House Republicans have differing ideas about what “mistakes” have been made. Here are some highlights. Chair John Mica […]