Report: Bush-Era Transit ‘Cost-Effectiveness’ Rule to Cost Charlotte $67M

When the Obama administration moved in January to undo a 2005 rule that made a federal "cost-effectiveness" rating the most important factor in determining which transit projects received funding, critics and even some transit advocates were skeptical, questioning whether the U.S. DOT would be able to legitimately quantify the community-building benefits of rail and bus networks.

Charlotte_SharonRdWest1.jpgThe new light rail line in Charlotte, North Carolina. (Photo: UrbanRail.net)

But federal officials continued to describe the shift as a significant boost for local transit planners, who will no longer need to design the budgets for new transit lines around the confines of a cost-effectiveness formula that attempted to measure the "incremental cost per hour" for each traveler.

Those who cheered the demise of the cost-effectiveness rule got new ammunition today from Greenwire, which sent a reporter to Charlotte, North Carolina, to track the city’s plans for expanding its three-year-old light rail line.

The full story is available only to subscribers, but it puts a $67 million price tag on local  transit planners’ mandate to comply with the Bush-era cost-effectiveness standard. As Greenwire’s Josh Voorhees explains:

 

Charlotte officials had originally wanted to build the
line — the first in a planned network spanning the metro area — with
three-car trains. But the project was scaled back to a two-car system
to comply with a complicated cost-effectiveness formula then at the
heart of the U.S. Transportation Department’s criteria for federal
funding.

"In order to get the score we needed, they told us
we had to find a way to cut the project’s scope," said John Muth, chief
development officer for the Charlotte Area Transit System. "We didn’t
really have other options if we wanted the federal funding."

Now, as the city plans the second phase of its light-rail project, a
three-car, 11-mile extension of the existing line from Uptown into
northeast Charlotte, it also must retrofit the existing track to carry
the longer trains. That means not only buying more rail cars, but also
lengthening platforms and boosting power distribution. Estimated price
tag of the retrofits: an additional $67 million.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Two Dems Propose to End Bush-Era Rule on Transit ‘Cost-Effectiveness’

|
New Starts, the main federal method for funding big-ticket transit projects, is considered sorely in need of a makeover by many in the capital. Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) (Photo: MPR) The program’s high bureaucratic hurdles, shoddy record-keeping, and often glaringly low ridership predictions got dissed earlier this year by House transportation committee chairman Jim Oberstar, […]

Transit Planners to Congress: Please Figure Out How to Fund Us

|
To all but the most ardent transit wonks, the phrase "New Starts" sounds like a motivational tape sold on late-night TV. But those two words actually represent Washington’s predominant mechanism to pay for major transit expansions — everything from expanding an existing rail station to building a new bus line. Minnesota’s Hiawatha rail line is […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Four-City U.S. DOT Tour Highlights Neighborhoods Where Highways Divide (NextCity) New Federal Rule Could Merge Metropolitan Planning Agencies (NWI.com) Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker Vetoes Vehicle Miles Traveled Tax (MassLive) U.S. News: American Auto Industry Is in Trouble Trial Underway for Driver Who Killed Complete Streets Engineer, Intern in Columbus (Dispatch) Charlotte Police Cracking Down on Drivers Who […]

Calling on Fans of Transit: Get in the Game

|
Rob Perks is the transportation advocacy director at the Natural Resources Defense Council. As someone who commutes to work on the Metro, I’m a big fan of public transportation. Earlier this week, as I was persusing the sports section of the Washington Post, I read a great story about a super fan. His name is Joel […]

10 New Rail, BRT Projects Selected for Funding by DOT

|
From bus rapid transit in Michigan to light rail in Arizona, ten new local transit projects are in line to receive federal capital funding under the President’s 2012 Budget proposal. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood today released a list of 10 new projects in nine cities that would receive a total of $569 million in funding […]