The Perils of Taking Transit Advice From an Alabama Senator

During yesterday’s Senate Banking Committee hearing on transit’s funding needs, the most emotional testimony came from Washington D.C.’s Metro chief, John Catoe — who, as the Washington Post reported, delivered an abject plea for federal aid to keep his system running safely.

shelby_richard_senator_r_al.jpgWould you take transit advice from this Alabama senator? (Photo: Left Eye on the Media)

Catoe’s rail network has become the locus of a national safety debate after a June 22 crash killed nine riders. Metro stands to receive $150 million as part of the U.S. DOT’s annual spending bill, but its needs in an era of record-high ridership and regional growth are much bigger: $7 billion over the next 10 years to keep the existing system in good shape, according to Catoe.

As the Post observed, the Banking panel’s chief Republican wasn’t sure that transit systems should get federal aid after putting off repairs in favor of capacity boosting:

Sen. Richard C. Shelby (R-Ala.), though, expressed concern that the
very systems requesting help put too much money into expanding their
capacity in past years without doing the maintenance they say is so
backlogged now.

"I know it’s a mixed bag," he said. "If you don’t grow, you can’t finish your system."

One wonders if Shelby is aware of the paltry resources that Congress has provided to transit agencies that want to maintain their existing systems without expanding rail lines.

The largest source of funding for equipment improvements, the Federal Transit Administration’s (FTA) fixed guideway program, has what the FTA chief describes as a formula without a strategy. Even so, the FTA reported in April that fixed guideway money should be doubled in order to keep urban transit in good working order.

Perhaps Shelby would prefer to see states step up and provide the lion’s share of money for transit repairs. After all, his home state opened the country’s first electric trolley network in 1886. Oh, wait — Alabama has provided zero dedicated state funding for transit since 1952.

  • Mark

    “Alabama has provided zero dedicated state funding for transit since 1952…”

    and a mere three years later, Rosa Parks became a household name, thereby forever sealing the fate of public transportation in mid sized cities below the Mason Dixon line.

  • Stu

    “…put too much money into expanding their capacity in past years without doing the maintenance they say is so backlogged now.”

    Gee, doesn’t this argument also apply to the massive network of roads we’ve built in the past several decades without thinking about what would happen, say, early in the 21st Century when all these roads need maintenance?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

On the Pitfalls and Benefits of National Transit Safety Standards

|
The second hearing in three days on the Obama administration’s proposal for national transit safety rules made headlines mostly for its affect on the Washington D.C. area, where Sen. Barbara Mikulski’s (D-MD) blistering critique of the local Metro rail system prompted high-level management switches. "There’s a saying in our business," APTA President William Millar (above) […]

Senators Hear From Obama’s Transit Chief-in-Waiting

|
One of the Capitol’s sad, secret truths is that members of Congress often skip committee hearings on issues of vital importance to their states — and today’s confirmation session with Peter Rogoff, the president’s nominee to lead the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), was no exception. Just three members of the Senate Banking Committee showed up […]