Toronto Has a Plan to Clear the Way for Streetcars Stuck in Traffic

Currently, streetcars get bogged down down in private car traffic on King Street, Toronto's busiest surface transit route. A new plan would divert private vehicles out of the path of transit. Photo: booledozer/Flickr
Currently, streetcars get bogged down down in private car traffic on King Street, Toronto's busiest surface transit route. A new plan would divert private vehicles out of the path of transit. Photo: booledozer/Flickr

Toronto’s busiest surface transit route could get a big upgrade as part of a year-long pilot project — if it clears the Toronto City Council this summer, where suburban interests have a history of rejecting transit initiatives.

Each day, the 504 streetcar carries 65,000 trips on King Street across downtown Toronto. But the streetcars get bogged down in motor vehicle traffic — about 20,000 private cars and trucks are on King Street daily — making the route painfully slow for riders.

“It’s a hugely busy route, but frankly, it doesn’t work,” said TTC chief executive Andy Byford in a video about the plan. “King Street is so congested, so the streetcars bunch, they gap, they get hopelessly snarled in traffic.”

The plan, announced jointly by the TTC and the City of Toronto, aims to keep curbs accessible for deliveries and drop-offs while eliminating the vehicles that most often block streetcars. On a mile-and-a-half of King Street between Bathurst and Jarvis streets, drivers would only be allowed to turn right. Through traffic and left turns would be prohibited. On-street parking would be eliminated and replaced with loading zones, taxi stands, bike racks, and space for streetcar passengers to wait.

By requiring that drivers turn right at each block along King Street, Toronto hopes it can clear the way for its streetcars. Image: The Globe and Mail
By requiring drivers to turn right at each block along King Street, Toronto hopes it can clear the way for streetcars. Image: The Globe and Mail

The new design would be a significant improvement from the current, traffic-clogged set-up, but Jarrett Walker at Human Transit notes that it’s far from perfect. “There are still compromises: traffic is still in the streetcar’s lane, and refuges for passengers to board and alight will be marked only with paint,” he writes. It also relies on police enforcement to keep drivers from turning left or continuing straight, and covers only a small section of King Street. Still, Walker says, “this plan is a critical step, and deserves enthusiastic support.”

The pilot project, developed by a team that includes Toronto urban design firm Public Work, Sam Schwartz Engineering, Gehl Studio New York, and Toronto-based Swerhun Associates, was revealed to the Globe and Mail on Saturday in advance of a public meeting on Thursday evening.

“Previous attempts to change downtown streets have raised the ire of suburban councillors, who argue that these are not just local roads but are important to traffic from around the city,” wrote the Globe and Mail’s Oliver Moore. “There can also be expected to be opposition from some businesses in the area.”

Despite the hurdles, it’s clear that the status quo on King Street is leaving Torontonians stuck in gridlock. If approved by the City Council in July, the one-year pilot project could be up and running in October.

  • mfs

    Maybe this could be done on 14th street in NYC during the L train shutdown. Maintains curbside access but discourages through traffic. Also a good option for Jay St in downtown Brooklyn.

  • Mark Northcott

    if theres going to be right turn only, then the majority of the intersections should have pedestrian only signals to avoid the inevitable increase in pedestrian collisions.

  • Ray

    They need to just charge a congestion fee for driving on any road that shares a streetcar. That will fix the problem without the need for unnecessary enforcement and forced turn lanes.

  • lagwagonmike

    why not just make King and Queen St. one way (each going a different way). Problem solved.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Will Toronto Get Cars Out of the Way of the King Street Streetcar?

|
Despite running through some of Toronto’s most densely populated areas, King Street is designed like a suburban road. Cars have dominion while the city’s streetcar has no dedicated right-of-way despite high ridership — so it sits in heavy traffic. But it looks that’s about to change. Toronto recently announced plans to overhaul King Street by 2017 with a pilot project to shift space from […]

Streetcars and Street Design

|
This morning on the Streetsblog Network, Yonah Freemark at The Transport Politic talks about streetcar plans in Washington, D.C. Without better street design, he argues, the capital’s streetcars could end up mired in traffic:   (Photo: rocket ship via Flickr) I have documented some of the quotidian situations that will result in delayed traffic as a […]

Transit-Oriented America, Part 3: Three More Cities

|
Part 3 in a series on rail and transit-only travel across the United States focuses on the final three cities of our journey. Part 2 looked at the first three and Part 1 presented an overview of our travel.  San Francisco Fully restored streetcars, cable cars, buses with and without pantographs, submerged and at-grade light rail, a […]

Making Room for Modes Other Than Cars

|
When we talk about competing modes of transportation we’re usually focused on the strained relationship between drivers and cyclists, or drivers and transit, or drivers and pedestrians. With so much street space taken up by cars, tensions also erupt, of course, between cyclists and pedestrians, and even cyclists and transit. We’ve written before about the […]

Will Barcelona’s “Superblocks” Proposal Work Well for Transit?

|
Barcelona is making waves with plans to test a concept it’s calling “superblocks.” The idea is to create nine-block squares of “citizen spaces” — about 400 meters on each side — where cars would be limited. Unlike the widely derided superblocks of the urban renewal era, Barcelona’s would be explicitly designed to preserve the street grid for walking and biking — only motor vehicle […]