Why Do “Best Places to Work” Rankings Overlook Commuting?

You’ve probably seen one of those rankings for your city that tells people where the “best places to work” are locally.

A terrible commute can certainly impact worker well being, so why is it being ignored in "best places to work" rankings? Photo: Wikipedia
A terrible commute can certainly affect your well being, so why not factor it into “best places to work” rankings? Photo: Wikipedia

They tend to examine criteria like salaries, benefits, corporate culture. But as Jeff La Noue at Baltimore-based blog Comeback City points out, they usually ignore one very important factor: the commute. And that’s a pretty serious omission, La Noue says:

Virtually every rush hour, one or more of our major regional highways is backed up when some unfortunate driver’s car is mangled in a so-called car-b-que. The DC area usually ranks among the highest in the nation for traffic congestion, while Baltimore isn’t far behind.

Beyond causing stress and eating up time, commuting by car can be dangerous. In 2010, Maryland had 493 traffic deaths. 296 were in passenger cars or light trucks vs one fatality in a bus. 383 fatal car crashes were on urban interstates.

Meanwhile, employers on the Baltimore Magazine list highlight commuting options with about the same frequency as company picnics and employer-paid pet insurance. Of the top 25, there are only eight employers with a walkscore rating over 70. A high walkscore can indicate whether an employee can walk to a place to eat, to live, or a central bus or transit line from their workplace.

La Noue goes on to list the best places to work in Baltimore by Walk Score ranking.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Political Environment challenges the almost unquestioned notion that suburbanites have a right to speedy commutes through the city of Milwaukee. Vibrant Bay Area considers how to make gas stations fit comfortably into the urban environment. And Reno Rambler comments on the ideological divide between cyclists who advocate for better infrastructure and cyclists who advocate for behaving like drivers.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

St. Louis: Plenty of Highways, Little Congestion, Long Commutes

|
Last week we wrote about the flawed measurement system employed by the Texas Transportation Institute in its annual Urban Mobility Rankings, which emphasize the free motion of cars over total time spent commuting. TTI’s rankings highlighted the relative mobility of cities like St. Louis, Buffalo and Detroit, while decrying the congestion of Chicago and Washington, […]

“Opportunity Score” Shows Best Places to Find a Job Without Owning a Car

|
Which places put economic opportunity within reach for residents who don’t own cars? There’s a new tool to evaluate housing locations according to the accessibility of jobs via transit and walking. Redfin, the company that runs Walk Score, today released “Opportunity Score,” which ranks millions of addresses across 350 cities based on the number of jobs within a 30-minute walk […]

Targeted Spending Helps Boost Kansas City’s Walkability

|
The Alliance for Biking and Walking released a big new report yesterday that measures the nation’s progress on active transportation. There’s a ton of data to nerd out on, but one thing that might be particularly interesting to local advocates is that the report shows biking and walking statistics for individual cities. It has details […]

Report: Commuters in Eugene, Oregon Have It Best

|
Today on the Streetsblog Network, Jonathan Maus at Bike Portland outlines a study conducted by financial websites TheStreet and Bundle which ranks the most and least expensive cities for commuters. According to the study’s authors, about seven in ten American communities are considered affordable based on housing costs alone. When commuting costs are factored into […]