Missouri Doubles Down on Highway Spending Despite Diminishing Returns

States everywhere are feeling the squeeze in their transportation budgets. As gas taxes stagnate, they either have to raise revenue or cut spending.

Missouri's gross state product has been under-performing the national average. Are more roads the answer? Image: nextSTL
Missouri’s gross state product has been under-performing the national average, despite a whole lot of highway building. Image: nextSTL

In Missouri, as lawmakers propose a state sales tax hike of 1 percent that would be spent almost entirely on highways, some watchdogs contest the state’s claim that it needs more revenue to take care of basic road maintenance. Richard Bose at nextSTL thinks the state shouldn’t throw good money after bad:

Before we rush to the polls this fall, let’s take stock on how our current system is performing.

Missouri Gross State Product (GSP) is up 8.3% 2000-12, while it is up 23% in the entire country. Clearly the new and expanded roads built in the ’90s and ’00s aren’t helping us out-perform the rest of the country.

Vehicle miles traveled on Missouri state highways is flat 2000-2012. So there’s little demand for more.

Next compare Missouri GSP per Vehicle mile traveled. This is up 7.1% 2000-12. We are getting more out of the traveling we do. The economy is changing.

State DOTs are living in the past. If one went to prospective investors and presented these projections for market growth vs. reality you’d be laughed out of the office.

So will doubling down on state highways make us wealthier? Is giving $8B over the next ten years to the state for this one purpose worth the opportunity cost?

It’s up to voters to decide.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Greater Marin says transit officials should be required to use their own service. Systemic Failure balks at the super-low minimum car insurance coverage required in California. And The Active Pursuit reports that some schools in Wisconsin are trying a winter walk-to-school day.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Midwest Govs Go All Out to Raise More Money for Highways

|
We’ve been watching how governors around the country are getting extra “creative” as they try to keep their transportation budgets solvent. Yesterday we witnessed an excise tax on bicycles floated in Washington State. But the award for the wildest funding scheme may go to renowned highway spender Governor Scott Walker in Wisconsin, who wants to […]

Will Missouri Voters Go Along With the Highway Lobby’s Money Grab?

|
Next week, Missouri voters will decide on Amendment 7 — a three-quarter-cent sales tax hike to pay for transportation projects that would be the largest tax increase in the state’s history. Construction industry groups have poured millions into convincing Missourians to pay $5.4 billion over the next 10 years. Will they bite? A coalition of pro-transit forces […]

Why a Broke State DOT Could Be Great for Missouri

|
In August, Missouri voters roundly defeated a sales tax increase supported by road building interests that would have dramatically boosted funding for the state DOT. During the run-up to the election, state leaders laid it on thick in their appeal for more road money, arguing that the fallout would be disastrous for public safety if […]