Boston Bike Report Wrongly Blamed Cyclists for Most Collisions
Last month, the city of Boston released a bike safety report, and it was something of a disaster.
Network blog Boston Streets explains the data was misinterpreted by the city’s bike director, and the report falsely claimed cyclists were responsible for most of the collisions in which they were involved:
Reports immediately focused on an unbelievable finding: cyclists running red lights were the most common cause of crashes in Boston. No doubt guilt-ridden drivers were relieved to learn that scofflaw cyclists were the problem all along.
So what happened? The Boston Cyclist Safety Report combines two crash data research efforts: one summarizing police reports and one revealing EMS data. These studies make up the second and third chapters, respectively, of the Report. Chapter 1 is essentially an executive report written by the city’s Bicycle Director, Nicole Freedman.
Freedman is responsible for erroneously reporting that red-light running was the most common crash contributor, despite that the claim is contradicted within the same report. And despite the fact that it flies in the face of every other bicycle safety study. Transportation professionals are well aware that right-hook crashes and “doorings” are far and away the most common bicycle crash types. How our city’s Bike Director could have overlooked this is truly puzzling.
Regardless of the gaffe, the report did convey some valuable information. Too many people are getting killed and injured on bikes in Boston, and they’re getting hurt most often in a handful of places. However, data from police and other primary sources is often vague and inadequate. “’Driver did not see bicyclist’ does not provide useful insight,” said Boston Streets.
Elsewhere on the Network today: Peninsula Transportation finds that taxpayers in Palo Alto, California, aren’t fond of the idea of chipping in for parking structures. PA Walks and Bikes says Pennsylvania has for the first time added a dedicated fund for walking and biking to the transportation bill. And Transit Miami reports that planners in Fort Lauderdale are leaving bike and pedestrian safety to a vote by neighborhood residents.