Tennessee DOT Moves Past Road-Widening as a Congestion Reduction Strategy

In the late eighties and nineties, every traffic issue the Tennessee Department of Transportation faced was assigned the same solution: a bypass. But over the years, the department has come around to a new way of doing things, according to 40-year TDOT veteran Ralph Comer. Comer says the current commissioner, John Schroer, wants to become known as the “no-bypass commissioner.” He simply believes there are usually more cost-effective ways of solving transportation problems.

"Context sensitive solutions" preserve main streets like this one in Franklin, Tennessee instead of turning them into high-speed thoroughfares. Photo: ##http://blog.westhaventn.com/bid/124337/Why-Franklin-is-the-Perfect-Place-for-Your-New-Franklin-TN-Home##Westhaven##

This way of thinking led Schroer, Comer, and the department into a conversation with Smart Growth America. They teamed up to examine the state of Tennessee’s transportation system and devise a path forward, bringing together an impressively diverse coalition, from the Tennessee Disability Coalition to the Sierra Club, the public transit association to the road builders association. One irrefutable fact brought them together: The TDOT project pipeline would cost nine times more to construct than available funding would permit. Something had to change.

Tennessee is in better fiscal shape than most states and is one of a small handful of states with zero debt – meaning it pays zero percent of its budget toward debt service, leaving a lot more for infrastructure. That’s a luxurious position in today’s economic context. So if a close examination of cost-effective transportation strategies can be transformative for Tennessee, just imagine what it can do for states even more desperate to get costs under control.

The report that came out of the TDOT/SGA sessions [PDF] isn’t a project-by-project prescription, and it isn’t binding. But it looks at “context-sensitive solutions,” rather than building the same road through vastly different landscapes.

“A U.S. highway through a rolling hillside is different from a U.S. highway in a suburban community is different from a U.S. highway through a small town where that highway is also main street,” said Roger Millar, who directs Smart Growth America’s Leadership Institute. The report adds that appropriately designed streets will encourage appropriate vehicular speeds, and Millar notes they can also revitalize downtown.

“We can’t afford single solution investments anymore,” Millar said. The transportation system needs to move people, goods, and services at the same time it supports the main street economy. The best part is that the “context-sensitive solutions” TDOT is looking at often mean canceling big-ticket road-widening projects in favor of greener approaches at a fraction of the price.

The report lays this bare:

TDOT cannot always solve congestion by building more, wider and faster state roadways. There will never be enough financial resources to supply the endless demand for capacity. In fact, TDOT currently has nine times more projects in its project list than available funding will cover.

Further, TDOT realizes that the “wider and faster” approach to road construction cannot ultimately solve the problem. Sprawling land uses are creating congestion faster than roadway capacity can be increased. The illustration [below] depicts this never-ending cycle of transportation and land use changes. TDOT intends to work to manage capacity by better integrating land use and transportation planning. The desire to go “through” a place must be balanced with the desire to go “to” a place. Roadways have many purposes, including providing local and regional mobility, offering access to homes and businesses, and supporting economic growth.

Source: ##http://www.smartgrowthamerica.org/documents/removing-barriers-in-tennessee.pdf##Removing Barriers to Smarter Transportation Investments##

Of course, TDOT isn’t a land use agency. So they’re partnering with local governments to collaborate on transportation and land use decisions. And, according to Millar, the commissioner is prepared to say, “If you guys are going to sprawl, we can’t support you. We can’t afford that. You guys are going to sprawl on your own. Or maybe we can do things a different way.”

What the agency can do on its own is “right-size” the projects on its list. “There may be a $40 million or $50 million [bypass] project that achieves a transportation objective,” said Millar. “And you can achieve 95 percent of that objective for 10 percent of the cost.” Maybe the solution is to remove curb cuts or optimize the traffic light timing on an existing congested roadway, allowing traffic to move more freely. Operational improvements like that can reduce congestion for a fraction of the price of adding a new bypass.

“What’s the appropriate solution?” Millar went on. “Do you spend the $50 million that you don’t have? Or do you spend $5 million and get 95 percent of the way there?” Looking at the problem that way generated a lot of consensus among the coalition.

Without a set of binding recommendations on individual projects, the report provides the next best thing: a set of performance metrics by which TDOT can evaluate projects. “It was suggested in the first meeting that important goals or metrics might include economic impacts, job generation, cost saving potential, applicability to capital improvements/maintenance/operations, sustainability, equity, and ease of implementation,” the report says.

By those criteria, many projects that have long been in the pipeline are now being reevaluated. For example, the planned county seat connector program would have linked all of the state’s 95 county seats to the nearest highway. But according to Comer, who serves as TDOT’s assistant chief of environment and planning, “County seats were established back in the 1800s to be the geographic center of the county, not necessarily the population centers.” So now the trick is to see what projects still make sense.

Comer remembers the investment studies the Federal Highway Administration used to do in the eighties. They called all affected parties together for ideas, as agencies still seek to do. “But what often happened,” said Comer, “is that if a state DOT was proposing an interstate widening project or a new interchange project, you would call the transit agency to come to the table, and you would ask, ‘What long range plans do you have for accommodating transit?’ And because they didn’t have any money, they would say, ‘Well, we really don’t have any plan.’ So the foregone conclusion was ‘Well, then you’re going to do the highway project.’ We’re trying to get away from that now.”

2 thoughts on Tennessee DOT Moves Past Road-Widening as a Congestion Reduction Strategy

  1. A couple of issues with the diagram above. First, the new development bings in new taxes. And, at least where I live in TN ( just outside Nashville), new homes are generally more costly than the median home price and are built ever closer together on ever-smaller lots. So each lot generates more taxes on average eben as each lot requires less infrastructure than in older neighborhoods. Developers build the local streets and sidewalks, so why doesn’t the newly-expanded tax base, having no immediate infrastructure needs, generate enough taxes to pay for state road expansion done on its behalf? Probably, new taxes go to fixing decrepid infrastructire in old neighborhoods instead of keeping up with the needs of the new neighborhoods.

    Second, there are major roads within Nashville that should have been widened as much as two generations ago. Drivers learn to take back roads to bypass crowded arteries. When the arteries are widened, the latent traffic goes back to the arteries, and planners seem to think the widening roads CREATE drivers when in fact they simply go to long ignoring the problem, letting motorists, and future developments, work it all out. Build the road FIRST, then that will increase property values along the road and entice development where you want it.

  2. LYP-I appreciate for your kind and generous sharing.Shop online at christian louboutin mall for a great selection of christian louboutin boots, christian wedding shoes,christian louboutin ankle boots and sandals for girls,women and men with free shopping on all orders.Welcome to luxury christian louboutin sale online store.The best christian louboutin at best price, free delivery,easy returns & exchanges,100% quality guarantee!Save 82% Off.Cheap christian louboutin daffodile makes a woman’s feet dazzle and shine even after the twelve strikes of midnight.Own a pair of stylish and wonderful christian louboutin is women’s lifetime pursuit. We offer christian louboutin red bottom shoes online shopping by an elegant but easy way. Shopping online at discount price for red sole signature designer.
    Order  products in christian louboutin sale store are free shipping.If you want to be more remarkable,do not miss christian louboutin daffodil. They are sexy and gorgeous christian louboutin.Welcome old and new customers,we will offer you the best service.All shoes has been worked by good craftsman and christian louboutin men for men by hand and this is the result of a careful selection.If you   are engaged in the vogue or you want keep the same pace with the trend,christian louboutin could be your best choice.It is really nice of you to share the excellent shoes information to others. christian louboutin shoes is absolutely representative of fashion and recreation,became a matter of course the popular protagonist of the season.christian louboutin outlet will try our best to satisfy you christian louboutin wedges.
    christian louboutin sale is french hot brand in the world,We provide different kinds of christian louboutin usa.Choose the   woman wearing louboutin slingback,often has realised that many men somehow to high-heeled shoes have deep interest,wear cheap christian louboutin sales shoes can easily outright conquest many men,can easily get many men worship,can easily make many men excited.In fashionable arena occupies a place   of christian louboutin ankle boot forever and always makes women fascination.christian louboutin outlet
     foot that one wipe enthusiastic red,no matter how plain clothes,they   were unable to hide the hostess as fire the lively personality.christian louboutin sandals is fashionable and beautiful, recently new appearance of new women’s   sandals,presenting an one colour profusion,design and material   collocation also ingenuity, pretty,both restoring ancient ways,full of female lasting appeal,sweet call a person fondle admiringly
    christian louboutin shoes sole design very clever,”catch” the selling point of sight let woman enchanted,sexy very narcissistic is frowsty coquettish,imagine a man to follow his sole after the line of sight of red,women must have is willing to pay. The identification of the “red sole degree is high,it’s another benefit is let female stars free advertising.christian louboutin sale shoes as a woman’s external wearing choice embodies her connotation,her taste,her pursuit of her life,understanding.christian louboutin sandals is a woman’s life cannot resist temptation of summer follow sandal high is undoubtedly the most powerful-naked fiber foot,Dan red nutmeg, summer air fragrance in stimulating fashion masters of inspiration,the perfect cheap christian louboutin daffodile,in people the envy of look in the eyes supports a pieces of living color.Delicate the luxury of girl for oneself of each clothes to acquire a   pair of high heels to match,but always than a double take christian louboutin 2012 to reality.
    Whether you are what kind of woman need to wear a pair of christian louboutin shoes on the red carpet,your choice,we are unable to intervene,but you should know that Mr.Bhutto’s name.christian louboutin outlet today has five stores in the United States,two in New York the rest of South Beach Plaza in Los Angeles,Las Vegas and Orange state,some christian louboutin sale stores are planning to open in the Bal harbour,Boston and Chicago.The famous U.S. talk show host Oprah Winfrey,christian louboutin sandals is an art,recent and famous director David Lynch co-operation,his collection of shoes do one called "Idol"exhibition.R &B singer Ciara,Jay-Z’s song with the lyrics of christian louboutin canada content.
    Red soled christian louboutin shoes‘s signature logo,highlighting women’s lovely,beautiful,quieter and mature sexy christian louboutin sale store favorite with a variety of bright colors,especially open-toed style won him favor with the soleNama red flag,the performance of a woman with high heels the sexiest,swaying side.No wonder so many stars are even willing to free to speak for him,showed off alone belong to the christian louboutin outlet‘s style on the red carpet.Frenchman christian louboutin sales world is absolutely impossible to ignore.It is a favorite of European and American actress!”Red shoes” to identify high,another advantage is that the female stars free advertising.See the red soles of christian louboutin uk,the fundamental need to find the logo.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This Is the Kind of Leadership We Need From State DOTs

“A breath of fresh air” — that’s how Chuck Marohn at Strong Towns describes this interview with Tennessee DOT Commissioner John Schroer. In this video, produced by Smart Growth America, Schroer describes what he is doing to make Tennessee’s the “the best DOT in the country.” Here are some of the highlights: We did a top-to-bottom review and we looked […]

How State DOTs Waste Money Bailing Out Local Planning Mistakes

A few weeks ago, we featured a video of Tennessee Department of Transportation chief John Schroer describing the reforms he’s applying at his agency. One problem he pinpointed — and this happens to every state DOT — is when local governments ask his DOT to spend big sums of money fixing transportation problems that could have […]

A State DOT’s Unshakable Highway Fixation

The South Carolina Department of Transportation is sometimes still familiarly known as the “highway department.” That was, in fact, the agency’s proper title until 1977, when it was changed by order of the general assembly to the Department of Highways and Public Transportation. In many ways, though, the old name still fits. In the 2009-10 […]

Obama Names Transpo Transition Team

The Obama-Biden transition team today unveiled its "Agency Review Teams" — the people charged with "a thorough review of key departments, agencies and commissions of the United States government, as well as the White House, to provide the President-elect, Vice President-elect, and key advisors with information needed to make strategic policy, budgetary, and personnel decisions […]