In Virginia, Imagining a Less Disruptive Alternative to a Highway

On the north side of Charlottesville, Virginia, Route 29 is congested. So of course county officials immediately zeroed in on the most expensive, most disruptive course of action: building a $245 million bypass.

In the above video, a local environmental group is proposing a different solution. The Southern Environmental Law Center says the problem could be solved for a lot less than $40 million a mile — with just a few key interventions.

Sean Tubbs at Network blog Charlottesville Tomorrow has this report:

“We put this video together to highlight better approaches to solving traffic problems on U.S. 29,” said Morgan Butler of the Southern Environmental Law Center on Thursday. “The community itself has developed an approach that is far less damaging than the bypass; it’s more cost-effective, and it provides benefits that the bypass simply does not.”

In June, the Commonwealth Transportation Board awarded a $136 million contract to design and build the bypass to a team consisting of Skanska-USA and Branch Highways. However, the Skanska-Branch team cannot begin work on the final design until after the Virginia Department of Transportation completes an environmental assessment. The last study, known as an environmental impact study, was concluded in 2003.

The Federal Highway Administration is expected to determine in the fall if further scrutiny is required. The environmental groups hope the FHWA will make a decision that stops the bypass once again.

While local authorities seem to be bent on building the bypass, proposing an alternative — and proposing it in video — is a smart and increasingly common strategy. Charleston environmental group the Coastal Conservation League was able to help successfully halt the 8-mile Mark Clark Expressway using a well-designed and accessible alternative plan. In Portland, Spencer Boomhower’s animated condemnation of the Columbia River Crossing highway project has been viewed more than 2,000 times. He even followed up with a “common sense alternative.”

Elsewhere on the Network today: Bike Portland reports that a local business journal recently published an editorial lauding bicycling’s important role in the economy. Systemic Failure boils down the recent New York Times story about a lawsuit threatening Delhi’s BRT system: The small percentage of residents who drive feel entitlement to the entire street. And the Wash Cycle shares results from a study of fatal bike crashes over a four-year period in Ontario.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Virginia DOT Using Flawed Data to Justify Charlottesville Bypass

|
Much of the time, what drives transportation investments in America isn’t independent studies or cost benefit analyses — it’s politics. The sad truth is, rather than evaluating the strength of a proposal, studies from transportation agencies serve mainly to justify projects that political actors have chosen to pursue. Here’s a good example from Charlottesville, Virginia. […]

Charlottesville, Virginia to Bypass Years of Careful Planning

|
Charlottesville, Virginia is a true stand-out in growth management in the South. Despite strong development pressure, this mid-sized city, which is home to the University of Virginia, has developed a growth boundary to help preserve its scenic natural surroundings and quaint, small-town feel. After all that careful planning and forethought, it pains me to have […]

Tea Party Conspiracy Theorists Descend on Charlottesville, VA

|
Unless you are a member of the Tea Party or a United Nations historian (or you followed the 2010 Colorado governor’s race), you’ve probably never heard of Agenda 21. But this obscure 1992 resolution of the United Nations figures prominently in a conspiracy theory that is being used to undermine community planning efforts around the […]

VA Gov Bob McDonnell Boots Bypass Opponent From State Transpo Board

|
Well, there’s no longer any question whose side Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell is on when it comes to the controversial Western Bypass in Charlottesville. Whether the locals favor this project or not, the 6.2 mile, $300 million bypass, just north of the University of Virginia, clearly has some friends in high places. Sean Tubbs at Charlottesville […]

Critical Mass: Good for Cycling or Bad PR?

|
There’s been a lot of discussion in the blogosphere lately about the merits of Critical Mass, the long-running, monthly group ride that has taken hold in cities around the world since its debut in San Francisco nearly 20 years ago. In many cities, Critical Mass has been a powerful force for building a community of cyclists. […]

SC DOT Responds to Cyclist Death By Considering Bike Ban

|
For almost two decades Charleston cyclists have been using the James Island Connector — a highway-like corridor that is one of the only points of entry to the peninsula that is the city of Charleston. After the recent death of a cyclist, the South Carolina Department of Transportation decided it might not be legal for […]