How Urban Areas Get Stiffed on Transportation Spending

Today on the Streetsblog Network, a post from Aaron Renn on New Geography about the anti-urban bias in transportation spending. Renn points out that when it comes to the amount of taxes they contribute and the amount of funds they get back from the government, the nation’s cities all too often get the short end of the stick — to the ultimate detriment of regional economies.

It’s a complicated question, and we suggest that you go and read his very thoughtful post in full. Here’s a taste:

4180547998_2fa134c222.jpgToo many roads to nowhere. (Photo: Peter Zarria via Flickr)

Among urban and rural areas, who subsidizes whom?

It’s methodologically difficult to measure net taxation, but the
studies that have been done suggest that, contrary to the belief of
some, urban areas are big time net tax donors. For example, a recent Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute study found that Indiana’s urban and suburban counties generally subsidize rural ones.…

Exhibit A is transportation. Two-thirds of Americans live in large metro areas, yet less than half the federal transportation stimulus funds are going to the top 100 metro areas.
Missouri is spending half its stimulus money on 89 small counties that
account for only a quarter of the state’s population. In Ohio, the
state cancelled plans to spend $100 million in stimulus funds on the
crumbling Cleveland Inner Belt bridge in order to divert them to paying
for a $150 million bypass around Nelsonville — a town of only 5,000
people. This is part of a plan to construct a four-lane divided highway
into sparsely populated southeast Ohio as part of a “build it and they
will come” economic development plan. Mecklenburg County, NC, the
state’s largest and home to Charlotte, received only $7.8 million out
of the first $423 million in projects in that state. The Atlantic
Monthly described this as a contest between a “mayor’s stimulus” and a “governor’s stimulus” — and the governor won.

State after state has rural “roads to nowhere.” Without any
legitimate economic development strategy on offer for depressed rural
areas and small industrial cities, salvation is said to lie in access
to four lane highways. The logic is that until every county in America
is crisscrossed with these things, somehow residents are deprived of
their due. This plays well to rural resentment, allowing people who are
by nature proud believers in self-reliance and dismissive of welfare to
claim instead that they’ve been cheated out of their “fair share” of
transportation money.…

Regardless, a lack of transportation investment is crippling our
cities, many of which have congested, crumbling roads and shaky
bridges….[G]overnance reform at the state level is critical to
bring transportation funding allocations in line with real population
and economic development measures. That’s not to say that rural areas
should get no funding. There are many areas where legitimate state
funding is warranted, such as replacing substandard bridges or
correcting roads with dangerous geometry. But that doesn’t mean states
should spend huge amounts of money on large rural expansion projects of
dubious value that rob urban areas of the funds needed for projects
with genuine transportation merit and real economic development
potential.

More from around the network: Westside Bikeside has problems with a plan to use federal funds for a $30 million bike path along the beach in Los Angeles. Biking in LA sees it another way. And Bike Delaware News has an open letter asking Rep. Mike Castle to support the Active Community Transportation Act.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Chicago Commuter Rail Spends Big on Trucking

|
Chicago’s commuter rail agency will be raising this bridge to help trucks pass underneath, relying exclusively on transit funding. Photo: The Urbanophile Transit funding these days is, needless to say, scarce. Across the country, transit agencies are slashing services to cope with the gaping fiscal holes left by the recession. More than ever, every dollar […]

The Small Indiana City That’s Embracing Livable Streets

|
Kokomo, Indiana, has put resources and energy into developing streetscape features to calm traffic and provide more space for walking and biking, Aaron Renn reports. Photo: Urbanophile With a population of about 60,000 and a formerly industrial economy, Kokomo, Indiana, is not the type of city that recent economic trends have favored. But Aaron Renn […]

The Persistence of Job Sprawl in Smaller Cities

|
We wrote a few weeks ago that some early signs had emerged indicating the proliferation of suburban corporate office parks could be on the wane. That was a matter of some debate among readers. Aaron Renn at the Urbanophile has analyzed the situation further. His take is that downtowns in tier-one, global cities are in […]

Talking Headways Podcast: It Costs More to Drive Til You Qualify

|
The topic this week is housing affordability and transit, with guests Shima Hamidi, Reid Ewing, and John Renne. They discuss their recent paper in the journal Housing Policy Debate, “How Affordable is HUD Affordable Housing?” As it turns out, a lot of HUD rental assistance is spent in areas with high transportation costs. We talk about the impetus […]