When State DOTs Run Amok: $266M For Widening, Crumbs For Waterfront

Streetsblog New York reported last week on the state DOT’s expensive plan to widen part of the Major Deegan Expressway in the southwest Bronx, even as the agency fails to maintain upstate bridges. 

deegan_sheridan.jpgMore lanes, or more housing and parks? (Image of
proposed Deegan Expressway widening: NYSDOT. Image of the community’s
plan for a de-commissioned Sheridan Expressway: SBRWA)

The dubious Deegan project sucks up $266 million in the state DOT’s new
five-year capital plan, while more promising initiatives — like the potential removal of the Sheridan Expressway– languish without much money at all.

The DOT is considering tearing down the little-used Sheridan, a decision that would clear trucks off local streets and make room for housing, shops, and parks by the Bronx River.

But the capital plan sets aside just $2 million for the project. As advocates said in testimony today, that’s only enough cash to muddle through the studies already underway.

To repeat: New York state’s capital plan includes $266 million to widen a highway in an asthma-choked area of the Bronx, and $2 million for a project that could dramatically improve neighborhoods pummeled by truck traffic. Addressing a State Senate committee yesterday, advocates made the case for a different approach.

"We call on the NYS DOT to reinstate funding for the Sheridan project by reducing the size and scope of the Major Deegan Expressway project," the South Bronx River Watershed Alliance said in a statement. "With scarce resources, the agency must do a better job of prioritizing transportation investments that promote the safety, health and well-being of New York City residents."

The Tri-State Transportation Campaign submitted detailed commentary on the full capital plan, which you can read here. Here Tri-State explains why the New York DOT, which doesn’t expand highways to the same degree as other state DOTs, still has a weakness for widening certain types of roads.

NYS DOT often plans large or over built rehabilitation projects under
the guise of "bringing the roadway up to modern design standards."
While certain modern design changes can help improve safety, spending
millions of dollars, in some cases hundreds of millions, to simply
widen interchanges, intersections, or build additional lanes does not
make sense. Such projects often do little to solve congestion in the
long-run, and come with very high price tags at a time when we have no
money to waste.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

NYC Rejects Highway Teardown Without Completing TIGER-Funded Analysis

|
The Bloomberg administration has abruptly ruled out the possibility of tearing down New York’s lightly-trafficked Sheridan Expressway and replacing it with mixed-use development, jobs, and parks. Neighborhood advocates and electeds from the Bronx are vowing to fight the decision, which they say fails to follow through on the comprehensive analysis the city promised to conduct […]

What Can We Learn From an Unbuilt Highway in St. Louis?

|
Back in the 1960s, planners envisioned a series of expressways slicing through St. Louis. And almost all of the Bartholomew Plan, as it was known, was eventually built. Today St. Louis has among the most highway lanes per capita of any American city. These roads teed up a wave of urban flight and astounding population […]

Philly Gets a Boost From U.S. DOT to Mend Neighborhoods Split By a Highway

|
Earlier this year Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx said he wants to help repair the damage done to cities by highways. And this week U.S. DOT took some steps to make that happen, announcing the winners of its “Every Place Counts Design Challenge.” The four chosen cities (out of 33 applicants) will get technical assistance from U.S. DOT to tear down or cap highways, or […]

Highway Boondoggles: Pennsylvania’s Mon-Fayette Expressway Plan

|
In a new report, Highway Boondoggles 2, U.S. PIRG and the Frontier Group profile the most wasteful highway projects that state DOTs are building. Today we highlight Pennsylvania’s $1.7 billion Mon-Fayette Expressway plan, a highway plan that has outlived its reason for being.  The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission and the state Department of Transportation have been trying to […]