Bush Transpo Secretary’s Biggest Disappointment: Bush

DC Velocity magazine has just released a lengthy interview with Norman Mineta, the Bush-era transportation secretary and former Democratic member of Congress.

min0_011.jpgFormer U.S. DOT chief Mineta (r.), with his biggest disappointment. (Photo: Academy of Achievement)

In the interview, Mineta — who now works on infrastructure at the consulting firm Hill & Knowlton — spoke openly about the transportation funding crisis and called for the Obama administration to reconsider its opposition to a VMT tax:

I think the "Vehicle Miles Traveled" program ought to be seriously
considered. Even if you go to a VMT, you still have some form of tax.
But the beauty of the VMT approach is that all you look at is how many
miles you travel on the highway. It captures activity regardless of
energy source.

Mineta also showed refreshing candor in describing his biggest disappointment during five years at the Bush White House: the former president’s staunch refusal to reform the gas tax. Mineta explained that he planned in 2001 to pay for a $330 billion federal transportation bill increase gas taxes by 2 cents per gallon in the first, third and fifth years of the six-year legislation. But here’s what happened, per Mineta:

We went to the Oval Office, and after we went through the entire
presentation, President Bush takes a marker, circles the gas tax
increases, and says, "Norm, I don’t want any of those tax increases.
Get those out."

So Mineta pared his proposal back, suggesting merely to index the gas tax to inflation — which has already worked for six state governments and could soon become law in Bush’s home state of Texas. But alas, Bush couldn’t let go of his fondness for running deficits in the name of "fiscal conservatism":

We returned to the Oval Office, went through the presentation, and
afterward President Bush said, "Norm, that’s a tax increase. Get that
out." So I then took all the unobligated surplus, left $1 billion in
the highway trust fund, and used the balance to build a $267 billion
surface transportation program that Congress finally passed in 2005.
Not long after, the administration asked for an $8 billion infusion of
general funds into the highway trust fund so it wouldn’t be running a
deficit by 2007.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

House Celebrates Norman Mineta, Ignores His Ideas

|
Congratulations are in order for former DOT chief Norman Mineta. The House of Representatives just voted, 384 to 0, to honor his accomplishments. Unfortunately, they still can’t muster the votes to follow his urgent recommendations: that the country ramp up our investments in infrastructure, that we switch from a gas tax to a VMT fee, […]

Former US DOT Bosses Call for Mileage Tax and Congestion Fees

|
Bottlenecks cripple our productivity, and transitioning among modes of transportation remains a convoluted and inefficient process nationwide, with some major cities being the few exceptions. Concerns about the environmental impact of these inefficiencies further highlight the need for systems that offer quick, interconnected and efficient means for transportation. The message today from two Republican-appointed former […]

Is Transpo Funding Fundamentally a PR Problem? Five Ex-DOT Chiefs Discuss

|
How can you convince Americans that transportation is important enough to invest in? That’s the question that brought together five former U.S. Transportation Secretaries this week at the University of Virginia’s Miller Center. James Burnley was deputy secretary and then secretary under President Reagan. He took the position that “75 percent” of the public “gives […]

Yes, You Can Move the Needle on Public Support for a Gas Tax Hike

|
Public support for increasing the federal gas tax rises if revenues will be spent to combat global warming. Graphic: Mineta Transportation Institute Last week, USA Today reported rather gleefully that the U.S. gas tax has never been lower. Having remained unchanged at 18.4 cents per gallon since 1993, American drivers are now paying half as […]

A Dear Abby for Transportation Secretaries: Advice From Foxx’s Predecessors

|
Yesterday, the University of Virginia’s Miller Center invited six former transportation secretaries to talk about the possibilities of presidential influence over transportation and to give advice to Charlotte Mayor Anthony Foxx, whose nomination for the job was announced that same day. James Burnley (1987-1989, under Reagan): “His challenge is to establish his leadership as early […]

T&I Chair Bill Shuster Complicates Matters With Push for VMT Fee

|
All options may be on the table for funding transportation, but Bill Shuster has chosen his. Rep. Shuster, head of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, hasn’t been willing to commit to any one proposal for funding transportation until now. And his choice may make things complicated. At a Bloomberg Government event yesterday, Shuster came […]