America’s Big Fat Road Problem

America has a fat problem. You knew that, right? But it’s not just the people who are fat. It’s the roads.

That’s the subject of a very insightful post from Streetsblog Network member Tom Vanderbilt, author of the book Traffic and keeper of the blog How We Drive. He makes the connection between the two kinds of fat — on our bellies and on our streets and highways — citing the work of Brian Wansink, an expert on consumer behavior and the human reaction to food who has made a particular study of ever-increasing portion size in the American diet:

2129848483_e5619c8a50.jpgPhoto by circulating via Flickr.

Wansink suggests the larger the portion size, the less accurate the estimation of calories consumed becomes.

What does this have to do with the road? There is an interesting story in how the rise in portion size — often associated (as Wansink notes) with fast-food restaurants — historically tracks the huge
increase in miles traveled (183% growth in per-person miles from 1969 to 2000, a period in which the number of persons itself increased only 41%), which itself is associated with the rise of those same
restaurants; not to mention the much-debated work linking obesity to density and travel modes.

But I had a different comparison in mind: The way the size of our roads affects our behavior in “consuming” them as drivers. This was brought home to me again in a recent video made by a group called Park Slope Neighbors,
which is working to reduce the size of streets like Brooklyn’s Prospect Park West (a five-lane thoroughfare, two lanes of which are dedicated to parking). As the video below shows, the speeds on the street are routinely in excess of the 30 MPH limit…

One of the recommendations for Prospect Park West is to put it on a “road diet,” a deeply suggestive phrase in light of Wansink’s research. A separated bike lane would be a great place to start — and would reduce the frequent cases of cyclists using the adjacent sidewalk. But something has to be done to change the context of the street. Underutilized by cars much of the time, it is an inefficient use of urban space, and its capaciousness sends a set of powerful signals to the driver, more powerful than whatever speed limit signs may be present. It represents, to paraphrase Wansink, “mindless speeding.”
People drive fast because it feels like they should. They see a wide road, and don’t give themselves much time to see anything else.

Vanderbilt argues that signs telling people to slow down, PSAs about the dangers of speeding and even police enforcement of speed limits can’t do what road diets can. Just the way all the calorie-count posters in the world can’t stop us from finishing a big bowl of ice cream when it’s put in front of us. Check out this related post from St. Louis Urban Workshop. Interesting stuff.

Other interesting stuff from the network: Hub and Spokes is talking about "the fight of a generation" for transit advocates, EcoVelo links to a cool video showing the reasoning behind "Idaho stops" for bicycles, and Carfree USA links to a Wall Street Journal article that wonders if Americans are changing their gas-guzzling ways for good.

  • Regarding this and the Park Slope Neighbors video:

    All excellent points but NYC also has very little to no speeding enforcement that I’m aware of.

    There are wide roads with low speed limits in New Jersey towns where the police have a reputation for strict speed limit enforcement. Due to this enforcement, speeding on these roads is minimal. However if you’re a stranger and don’t know the reputation of the police, the nature of the wide road still suggests to the driver to “put the pedal to the metal.”

    Still I agree that wide roads in residential and urban areas, particularly those with unnecessary capacity should be put on a diet immediately.

  • Valerie Broadwell

    Although not directly related to the article, I wanted to comment that I just returned from an 8-day trip to Maui and was saddened at how auto-dependent the island is. It is a place with perfect weather for walking and biking, yet doing so is risky most places. The big hotels have built a luxurious trail alongside the beach but it stops where the resorts stop. Nobody walks from the resorts to anywhere; all drive. I wonder if the car rental companies have been active lobbyists opposing sidewalks and bike lanes.

  • oscarfrye

    i, too was saddened by auto-centric hawaii

    back to brooklyn, i agree enforcement (or lack thereof) is part of the problem. plenty of laws are on the books, but get ignored constantly..i say bring on the speeding enforcement cameras, the more the merrier.

  • “(183% growth in per-person miles from 1969 to 2000, a period in which the number of persons itself increased only 41%)”

    I think you mean 83% growth. America’s per capita VMT has roughly doubled since the 1960s.

    I suspect someone saw a report saying that per capita VMT in 2000 was 183% of what it was in 1969, and they thought that meant 183% growth, while it actually means 83% growth.

  • Doug

    It’s a mish-mosh of the old “If you build it, they will come.” With roads, if you build curb extensions, bike lanes, eliminate lanes and provide less space for cars, drivers will behave differently (or not use those roads at all) and larger number of pedestrians and bikers will come out to use the same space that they once avoided.


Wisconsin Over-Invests in New Roads Destined for Underuse

Scott Walker, maybe we would respect your decision to pull the plug on high-speed rail in your state a little more if you weren’t such a hypocrite about transportation spending. The Wisconsin governor refused to pony up an estimated $4.7 million a year to provide 21st century intercity rail service to his constituents. But he’s only […]

The Freezing NYC-DC Bike Ride to Support Women in Cycling

The 2014 National Bike Summit is underway in our nation’s capital, starting with the Women’s Bicycling Forum, with its focus on expanding the share of women on two wheels. You can follow along on Twitter at #womenbike. In 2009, according to the League of American Bicyclists, women accounted for just 24 percent of bike trips […]

Funding Uncertainty Plagues Highways, But They Still Get Built

It’s funny how there always seems to be enough money for highways, but never enough for transit. Around the country, from Houston to Portland to New York, there are head-spinningly enormous highway construction projects about to get built, even though no one really knows how to pay for them. These projects don’t move forward because they’re […]

Scott Walker, Posterboy for Government Waste

It’s no secret that Scott Walker is basically running for president of the Tea Party from the governor’s seat in Wisconsin. But the fact is when you examine his policies, they’re not conservative at all. In fact, they’re wasteful. On transportation in particular, Walker is a consummate borrow-and-spender (particularly if that spending benefits his buddies […]