What Does Beauty Have to Do With Sustainability?

Today on the Streetsblog Network, we step back and take a look at a philosophical question, courtesy of Kaid Benfield at NRDC Switchboard. As we go forward into the 21st century, trying to create sustainable communities, how do we deal with the aging relics of the 20th century’s development patterns?

3305919757_5176ed4360_m.jpgCan we make beauty a criterion for preservation? Photo by Sarah Goodyear.

Are we going to start saving Walmarts, which the National Trust has opposed in one community after another, when they are 50 years old just because they are 50 years old?  The date is not all that far away.  And, make no mistake: they will be representative of a period and style of architecture.  If that’s the principal test, they will pass.  What about urban freeways that sliced through and destroyed historic neighborhoods?  They, too, are now part of history.

Benfield argues that using beauty as a criterion for preservation could help. But who is to define it? Read what he has to say and let us know what you think.

Big news and an invitation from our friends at Transportation for America: This Thursday, Feb. 26, at 10:30am, they’ll be rolling out their national campaign platform, which calls on the president and Congress "to launch a new federal transportation mission that puts an end to America’s oil dependency, helps us compete and thrive in the 21st century, and brings opportunity to all Americans." It’ll be held at the U.S. Capitol, and if you’re in DC you should head on over to hear people like Rep. Earl Blumenauer talk about the future of transportation in America.

Plus: Trains for America has news about the possibility of more funding for high-speed rail, Greater Greater Washington highlights the concerns of older pedestrians, and The Overhead Wire talks about dedicated funding sources for mass transit.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The New Dynamics That Are Eroding the Market for Sprawl

|
The argument that sprawl is the natural product of market forces and consumer preferences is ringing a little more hollow with each passing day. While charlatans like Wendell Cox use overly simplistic analyses of Census results to argue that the urban renaissance is a figment of our collective imagination, the underlying trends tell a different […]

In Flint, Trying to Reinvent a Shrinking City

|
Yesterday on the Streetsblog Network, we looked at the concept of "resilient cities" — an idea that some of our commenters on Streetsblog NY and Streetsblog LA sites frankly weren’t buying. Today, we have a post from Streetsblog Network member Smart Growth Around America about a city that is desperately searching for some definition of […]

When Will the Environmental Movement Embrace Cities?

|
Everyone has a few of those hippie friends. They love nature, so they live 50 miles from the city in a 10-acre “farm.” They’re able to grow some of their own food. But they have to commute two hours round trip to get to job opportunities, not to mention the trek to the grocery, church, […]

Livable Streets or Tall Buildings? Cities Can Have Both

|
Kaid Benfield’s new blog post on density is getting a lot of buzz over at NRDC’s Switchboard blog. Benfield, a planner/lawyer/professor/writer who co-founded both LEED’s Neighborhood Development rating system and the Smart Growth America coalition, has some serious street cred when it comes to these matters. And on this one, he’s with Danish architect Jan Gehl, […]

Livability and the GOP: A Conversation With HUD’s Mariia Zimmerman

|
Perhaps the Obama administration’s greatest contribution to building more livable, less traffic-choked communities has been the new partnership between three agencies — DOT, EPA, and HUD — which are helping towns and cities grow more sustainably, using strategies from brownfield redevelopment to the provision of affordable housing along transit corridors. The agencies have collaborated to […]

New Equity Atlas Tells a Story About the Future of Denver (With Maps!)

|
As more cities look to revive or expand their transit networks in the face of rising gas prices and maddening congestion, planners have had to remain vigilant to ensure that underprivileged communities are not displaced or adversely affected by the same transit improvements that could offer them numerous benefits. A few different techniques have emerged […]