The Power of Moses: Please Wield Responsibly

An op-ed piece by Eleanor Randolph in today’s New York Times finds yet another lesson in the current re-examination of Robert Moses’s legacy. Randolph looks at the enormously powerful entities, usually known as authorities, that Moses left behind: "public-private hybrid[s] that can collect fees, take on debt and build things with little government interference."

Randolph points out that despite reforms over the past few years, the most influential authority, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, still operates outside many of the laws that cover government agencies, including public-meeting and freedom of information laws. And, given the enormous importance of Port Authority holdings, she rightly calls for more accountability:

[I]f Lower Manhattan is now being rebuilt under the same system that Moses used to both advantage and disadvantage New Yorkers, today’s authorities must use their power more responsibly. Governor Spitzer should push for more rules imposing transparency and accountability, like requiring authority directors to sign an oath that they will carry out their fiduciary duties responsibly.

For the Port Authority, the New York and New Jersey Legislatures need to finally pass identical laws requiring public access to its enormous public works operations, which are, after all, the public’s business. Mr. Coscia, like many authority directors, now promises "transparency" at some level. But it is worth worrying that future builders might decide, as Robert Moses did regularly, that the best way to respond to public concerns is to send out the bulldozers at midnight.

  • Angus Grieve-Smith

    The thing that always amazed me in The Power Broker was that Moses was so cozily entrenched in his authorities that it took not one but two Rockefeller brothers to bring him down. If Nelson Rockefeller’s brother David didn’t just happen to be the CEO of Chase Bank, the bondholder for the TBTA, Moses might have remained in power until he died, and possibly even passed it on to a successor who could be building higways today.

    Randolph doesn’t mention the state’s Public Authorities Control Board, which is the only real check on the power of these authorities. Recently, when Speaker Silver has used his seat on the board to rein in one of them (usually the EDC at this point), it’s been framed by the media as “the fate of the project hinges on the nod of one man.” Yeah, only because all the rest have given up responsibility over it.

    These things are creepy and undemocratic, but nobody seems to be willing or able to get rid of them.

  • Nicolo Macchiavelli

    Not for nothing, Moses had nothing to do with Port Authority except as an antagonist and rival. Is it a public authority? Yes. Is the TBTA also?
    Yes. But does that mean that Moses had anything to do with PA? I don’t think so. I think that is called the “post hoc fallacy”.


The Clock is Ticking for PlaNYC

A delegation of approximately 30 members of the Campaign for New York’s Future are traveling to Albany today to meet with more than two dozen state legislators and other public officials. Today’s trip follows a series of meetings on Monday in which key coalition leaders joined Mayor Bloomberg to call for urgent State action on […]

Today’s Headlines

Obama to Send Jobs Bill to Congress Today (The Hill) Republicans Tone Down Partisan Rhetoric – But for How Long? (TPM, NYT) The Detroit Free Press Is Pessimistic that Congress Can Pass a Transportation Bill Fall Crunch Time, the Ultimate Test for Congress (Politico) Sadik-Khan Has ‘Done More for NYC Drivers Than Anyone Since Robert […]

What Should We Learn From Moses and Jacobs?

There is probably no more beloved figure in urbanism than Jane Jacobs, who fought to preserve some of New York City’s most treasured neighborhoods and who gave urbanists some of the field’s fundamental texts. As Ed Glaeser notes in the New Republic this week, Jacobs died in 2006 "a cherished, almost saintly figure," while her […]

Lautenberg Brawls With Port Authority Exec Over Tolling

New Jersey Senator Frank Lautenberg has been spoiling for a fight ever since the Port Authority raised tolls to cross into New York. And yesterday, he got it. Lautenberg invited Bill Baroni, the deputy director of the Port Authority, to testify at a Commerce Committee hearing that turned into little more than a showdown between the […]