When Your State DOT Starts Talking About “Relieving Congestion,” Alarms Should Go Off

Will Georgia make the burden of urban highways and traffic even worse for Atlanta, or will the state try a different approach on Interstate 75/85?

This area of Atlanta, south of downtown, was nearly completely obliterated by highway construction. Photo:  ThreadATL
This area of Atlanta, south of downtown, was nearly completely obliterated by highway construction. Photo: ThreadATL

In the 1960s, when Interstate I-75/85 was built through the heart of Atlanta, it wiped out whole neighborhoods. To this day, people living in its shadow deal with all kinds of ill effects: high air pollution, traffic, reduced mobility.

Now the state of Georgia is looking to reduce congestion on the corridor, saying “no idea is off the table.” But some ideas should be discarded right off the bat — like the notion that adding space for cars is going to solve the traffic problem.

Darin Givens at ThreadATL warns that the state’s approach might compound past mistakes. Or it could try something new — something that might actually work:

Some have suggested increasing capacity through a tunnel or a double-deck expansion. But doing that while leaving all the exits open means more car trips (induced demand) that create more exhaust and bring more vehicles into the city, all of them needing parking spaces.

And leaving things as they are means we continue with the current level of exhaust which is harmful to our health. Nothing happens in a bubble. Transportation decisions at the state level affect urban livability in the city.

Could we put Bus Rapid Transit lanes on all freeways in Atlanta and put BRT stations throughout the metro? And encourage transit-oriented development around those stations? It’s just a random thought, but it’s an example of the kind of regional-scale “fix” for congestion that would actually accomplish something, rather than trying to make the road design bear the weight of solution as the built environment all around it remains car-centric and lacking in transportation options.

More recommended reading today: The Political Environment says Scott Walker’s punitive attacks on transit and cities presaged what we’re seeing from the Trump White House. Modern Cities shares photos of an Orlando road diet that boosted walking and biking, improved safety, and led to growth in local businesses and jobs.

  • Vooch

    The people of Munich wish they had more lanes instead of this riverfront wasteland

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?list=PLzNM_rzDSme6P4gvpkVIVGEo1ta2TFMeS&v=m4RSUnLJD2U

  • Jason

    I assumed the guy was being dryly sarcastic, but I read the channel’s description:

    “The war on cars is very real. The all powerful bike lobby has joined with the pushy pedestrian lobby to force their insane ideas on us. This channel highlights the path these totalitarians are taking to deprive us of our freedom”

    And now Poe’s Law means I have no idea whether he’s being sarcastic or sincere. Watching his other videos did not help in figuring this out, either.

  • Vooch
  • Greg Manter

    Atlanta should be pleased if they have traffic congestion. It’s a feedback mechanism telling people to live closer to where they work. So the congestion should be celebrated as an effective deterrent to stupid commutes.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Three Concrete Proposals for New York City Traffic Relief

|
This Morning’s Forum: Road Pricing Worked in London. Can It Work in New York? Three specific proposals to reduce New York City’s ever-increasing traffic congestion emerged from a highly anticipated Manhattan Institute forum this morning. One seeks variable prices on cars driving in to central Manhattan, with express toll lanes and higher parking fees to keep things […]

Transit and Congestion, an Indirect Connection

|
Yesterday, Freakonomics linked to a new piece of research [PDF] on congestion that I’d been musing over for a few days. Let me quote the abstract here (paragraph break and emphasis mine): We investigate the relationship between interstate highways and highway vehicle kilometers traveled (vkt) in us cities. We find that vkt increases proportionately to […]