Hot Take: People Sometimes Bump Into Bike Lane Separators, and That’s OK

Photo: Gwynne Hogan
Photo: Gwynne Hogan

The basic point of a protected bike lane is that sometimes, vehicles bump into the objects that are doing the protecting.

I’m working on a post about the effects of the huge quick-build protected bike lane network installed by Seville, Spain, in 2007-2008. A new study of those outcomes by R. Marqués and V. Hernández-Herrador turns up this side note: Protected bike lanes tend to reduce bike-versus-car collisions, but they also seem to increase bike-versus-stationary-object collisions.

Here’s a relevant table from the study, published last month in the journal Accident Analysis and Prevention:

seville risk table

“The relative number of bicycle accidents other than collisions with motor vehicles increased after 2006,” the authors write. “This change seems natural, due to the concentration of cyclists in the cycle paths and the location of many cycle paths on or next the sidewalks.”

It’s also likely that some reporting error is involved here. But as American street designers look for the ideal form of bike lane separation, they frequently hear complaints that people are colliding with stationary objects, both while driving and while biking. The well-established practice of “traffic calming” could also be described as “placing large objects in locations where cars might hit them.” This strikes some people as unsafe, because it seems to invite collision. But the truth is that in general, well-designed traffic calming increases safety because people prefer to avoid hitting objects with their car, so on average people drive more slowly and carefully.

Similarly, it’s not unusual for some people who ride bikes to complain about narrow protected bike lanes, because they force slower speeds and seem to invite collision.

But though wide bike lanes generally make for better biking, slower biking isn’t always a bad thing, either.

Reasonable people will disagree over how and when to apply these ideas. But before we criticize a particular bike lane separator — whether we’re doing so from a driving or biking perspective — we should remember that there are worse situations on the road than colliding with a stationary object.

PlacesForBikes is a PeopleForBikes program to help U.S. communities build better biking, faster. You can follow them on Twitter or Facebook or sign up for their weekly news digest about building all-ages biking networks.

  • curiousKulak

    There is a separated bike lane on Cargo Way, from 3rd St to Heron’s Head Park. Virtually no part of that cyclone fencing has not been damaged by cars over the last 5 yrs. Cyclists may have hit it too, but they leave less evidence.

    Chain link fence is not really protective against cars & trucks; but it does keep cyclists contained. However, as a consequence of all the ‘accidents’, much of the fencing has been removed, which allows a cyclist to not be trapped in a narrow corridor that is up to 0.25 mi in length.

    Personally, I’d prefer a wide, clear road myself. Cars (and trucks) come crashing thru barriers all the time. Maybe slow down traffic another way.

  • Edward

    When I lived in Riyadh there was a barrier to prevent cars cutting in front of cars making a right turn. So they started cutting in front just before the barrier. They extended the barrier half a block to solve the problem. That evening there were three cars on top of the barrier with wheels dangling. Looked like mating beetles.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Bike Lanes Don’t Lead to Congestion, But Some of Them Should

|
Gretchen Johnson and Aaron Johnson have posted a nice debunking of typical “war on cars” rhetoric over at fivethirtyeight. Johnson and Johnson gathered before-and-after traffic data from 45 miles of streets where Minneapolis installed bike lanes. They also looked at how Brooklyn’s Prospect Park West bike lane affected traffic conditions. They found, in short, that after the installation of […]

U.S. DOT to Publish Its Own Manual on Protected Bike Lanes

|
Before the end of this year, the Federal Highway Administration will release its own guidance on designing protected bike lanes. The agency’s positions on bicycling infrastructure has matured in recent years. Until recently, U.S. DOT’s policy was simple adherence to outdated and stodgy manuals like AASHTO’s Green Book and FHWA’s own Manual on Uniform Traffic […]