Parking Madness Final Four: Niagara Falls vs. Louisville

Only three cities are left in the running for the Golden Crater in Parking Madness 2016. Today’s matchup will determine which insane parking will take on Federal Way, Washington, in the championship match.

Read up on the case for these two semi-finalists and vote below.

Niagara Falls

original-2

Niagara Falls is stunning, isn’t it? This is downtown, just a few blocks from the actual falls. Not exactly what you have in mind when you picture a scenic destination.

Niagara Falls’ population peaked in 1960 and has since fallen by more than half, to about 50,000. The proliferation of parking lots reflects not only the car-based transportation policies of the second half of the 20th Century, but a vicious feedback loop in which low land values discourage development. Citywide about 14 percent of building are vacant, according to the New York State Comptroller [PDF].

Louisville

unnamed-9

Here’s the parking crater in Louisville’s “SoBro” area, immediately south of downtown. Branden Klayko of Broken Sidewalk nominated this entry and highlighted the surface parking lots in red. He also sent in a historical photo of the same area, below. The parking crater, Klayko says, is intimately linked to the widening of Ninth Street — the one with a big median on the left side of the picture:

In the 20th century, Louisville’s Ninth Street was drastically widened to connect with an Interstate interchange. That widening combined with a barracks-style housing project split Downtown from the predominantly black Russell neighborhood and created what is locally called the Ninth Street Divide, a major problem still dividing the city today. At Ninth Street, the tall building is an old office building for the L&N railroad located next to the city’s train station. In the old photo [below], you can see the train sheds behind those structures. Needless to say, they have been removed and replaced with enormous parking lots.

Historically, much of what is today SoBro, pictured in the modern view, was residential and very dense. Only a handful of houses remain as the area was bulldozed for parking for Downtown and surrounding business and industry. In the center of the modern photo is Louisville‘s main post office, a massive, single-story building set back from the street that contributes little to the neighborhood.

Here’s the bird’s-eye view of roughly the same area in 1937 after a major flooding event. (Some of the present-day parking crater is captured in the bottom half of the photo, but it mostly captures the area directly north.)

unnamed-10

On to the voting. Which of these parking craters deserves a shot at eternal infamy?

Which city has the worst parking crater?

  • Louisville (58%, 135 Votes)
  • Niagara Falls (42%, 99 Votes)

Total Voters: 234

  • neroden

    Niagara Falls should win this for the sheer lack of buildings. It’s not just a crater, it’s a moonscape.

  • iSkyscraper

    A quality No.1 vs No.2 seed matchup, no suburban shopping malls or stadia this time. Have to go with Niagara Falls for the win because of the utter destruction of a downtown area – and this is the RENOVATED part of town, where the state dumped enormous sums of money to get the new casino built. Just out of frame are the magnificent falls (and a very healthy Niagara Falls, Ontario) on one side, and abandoned blocks on the other. Horrific.

    https://goo.gl/maps/aysGJoC2Kuo

    Louisville is impressive in its own right, but the surface parking there seems more a function of industrial zoning than anything else.

  • Georgianna Miller

    I have lived in Louisville for all my 58 years. I believe that Louisville could do better by getting rid of some of those large flat parking lots. And as much as I don’t want more concrete in the area, I also take in to consideration that there are lots of people who work downtown. There is a need for parking. Building multilevel parking garages could be the answer. An even better answer is to give downtown businesses an incentive to start ride share or alternative transportation where employees get credit for helping to reduce the need for all that parking.

  • neroden

    Niagara Falls should have won this. Sigh.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Parking Madness: Niagara Falls vs. Ann Arbor

|
We’ve seen some tough competition in the first round of the 2016 Parking Madness tournament. Yesterday, the parking lots of Federal Way, Washington, knocked out the parking lots around Montreal’s central rail station to advance. Today’s matchup looks fierce, with a crater in the tourist destination downtown of Niagara Falls, New York, facing off against a crater in the university town of Ann Arbor, […]

Parking Madness Elite Eight: Wilkes-Barre vs. Louisville

|
The final spot in the Final Four is up for grabs today, as we conclude the second week of the 2016 Parking Madness tournament. So far, parking craters in Dallas, Niagara Falls, and Federal Way, Washington have advanced to this elite stage of the competition. In today’s matchup, a waterfront parking crater in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, goes up […]

Parking Madness 2016 Championship: Federal Way vs. Louisville

|
This is it, folks. We started out with 16 parking craters in this year’s Parking Madness tournament, and just two remain: the asphalt-dominated downtown of Federal Way, Washington, and the grey parking lots in the SoBro section of Louisville, Kentucky. Louisville scored a major upset yesterday, beating many commenters’ pick to win it all, downtown Niagara Falls, New York. Meanwhile, Federal Way […]

Parking Madness: Dallas vs. Duluth

|
Had enough of ugly parking craters? Too bad! We’re barely halfway through the first round of Parking Madness. As such, Streetsblog will continue to assault your eyes with a surface parking horror show for days on end. Yesterday, the moonscape of downtown Niagara Falls annihilated a quaint-by-comparison crater in Ann Arbor. Today, perennial contender The Big D […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Federal Way vs. Dallas

|
Villanova is taking on UNC tonight, but the main event is here on Streetsblog, with the first Final Four match of Parking Madness 2016. Streetsblog readers have narrowed this year’s field of 16 down to four parking abominations in these cities: Niagara Falls, Louisville, Dallas, and Federal Way, Washington. Your votes will determine who gets into the […]

Parking Madness Elite Eight: Rutland vs. Niagara Falls

|
Every year Streetsblog asks readers to judge the Parking Madness competition — your votes winnow down 16 parking scars in a single-elimination tournament until we crown the “Golden Crater.” Yesterday, Federal Way, Washington, clinched the first Final Four spot. The second will go to either Rutland, Vermont, or Niagara Falls, New York. Rutland Submitter Andrew Fusco says the struggling-but-lovable town of Rutland, […]