Attention Cities: To Encourage Walking, Don’t Overlook the Basics

When it comes to making it easier and safer for people to get around on foot, is your city covering the basics? If you live in the U.S., odds are the answer is “Not by a long shot.”

A sure sign of a hostile walking environment. Photo: Tim Kovach
A sure sign of a hostile walking environment. Photo: Tim Kovach

Tim Kovach writes that his hometown, Cleveland, is getting good press for a zoning update intended to make parts of downtown more hospitable to pedestrians. Cleveland is also helping with a comprehensive planning guide that’s supposed to act as a blueprint for making Ohio cities more walkable.

But at the same time, Kovach says, the city is failing to do things like provide crosswalks and pedestrian signals where people want and need to walk. By prioritizing motor vehicle movement by default, Cleveland (like other cities) is overlooking the everyday experience of walking in the city.

If you know me or have read things that I’ve written here in the past, you probably realize that I’m a proponent of incremental progress. It’s great to push for the Big Things that can help shift paradigms, but we shouldn’t ignore the types of small, tangible changes that help people at the margins. It’s just as important to do the little things well.

There are a number of other criteria that we could use to judge Cleveland’s walkability. Are there mid-block crossings? (Yes.) Are they plentiful? (No.) Do they all have signs? (Some, but they aren’t maintained — see above.) Do drivers respect them? (Hell no.) Do all of the pedestrian signals have countdown timers? (Not even in downtown.) Do any of the pedestrian signals include verbal cues for the visually impaired? (No, given that I have had to escort a confused blind man across Superior Avenue.)

I certainly recognize that Cleveland is making very real progress in its effort to enhance bike and pedestrian infrastructure. But, all too often, we spend money on things that look nice or seem nice in theory, even as we overlook the little things that can make a tangible difference.

Elsewhere on the Network: Seattle Met makes the case for bike-share as bike infrastructure. And Systemic Failure reports that Morocco is outpacing the U.S. on high-speed rail.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

How Ohio’s Focus on Highways Suffocates Transit

|
What would it take to make transit a more appealing option in the greater Cleveland-Akron area? That question was posed to one of the area’s leading transportation officials recently. His answer didn’t focus on a big new project. Jason Segedy, head of Akron’s metropolitan planning organization, said the first step should be to start doing the […]

Even Places With No Congestion Are Widening Highways

|
For every transportation agency trying to innovate and update policies for the 21st century, there are several thoughtlessly widening highways like it’s still 1956. Case in point: Ohio DOT, which wants to widen three highways in the Cleveland region. Tim Kovach has been poring over the global urban congestion rankings produced by Tom Tom, the GPS company. TomTom says that out of […]

Why Free Black Friday Parking Is a Bad Idea

|
It can be hard for downtown retailers to compete with big box stores in the burbs. That’s why a lot of cities like to offer free street parking on “black Friday.” It sounds good in theory. But in practice, giving away parking might not do much to help central business districts, or their patrons. Citing […]

Cleveland: Progressing on Bike Policy, Still Falling Behind?

|
Here’s an interesting commentary on how livable streets advocates measure progress. Jacob VanSickle, executive director of Bike Cleveland (where I’m a volunteer board member), made an important point recently on the organization’s blog, one of our newest Network blogs. Cleveland has been making commendable strides in bike policy, with a new complete streets policy, three-foot […]

The Most Dangerous Places to Walk in America

|
Walking should be the healthiest, most natural activity in the world. It is, after all, one of the first things humans learn to do. But in far too many places, walking can be fatal, thanks to roads designed for speeding cars. In 2012, 4,743 pedestrians lost their lives in traffic collisions in the U.S., and […]