Making Private Donors Pay for Cincy Streetcar: A Classic Double-Standard

This is a make or break week for the Cincinnati streetcar. The Federal Transit Administration has given the city until Thursday to provide “unequivocal” assurances that the “paused” project will proceed at the agreed upon schedule, or the agency will revoke its $45 million grant to the project.

Construction on the Cincinnati Streetcar was "paused" earlier this month following the swearing in of a new mayor and city council. But if construction doesn't resume soon, the federal government is going yank $45 million in funding. Image: ##http://www.urbancincy.com/2013/12/editorial-localizing-operating-costs-for-streetcar-sets-dangerous-precedent/## Urban Cincy##
Construction on the Cincinnati Streetcar was “paused” earlier this month following the swearing in of a new mayor and city council. But if construction doesn’t resume soon, the federal government is going yank $45 million in funding. Image: ##http://www.urbancincy.com/2013/12/editorial-localizing-operating-costs-for-streetcar-sets-dangerous-precedent/## Urban Cincy##

The city’s new mayor, John Cranley, campaigned on a promise to kill the partially-constructed streetcar, then made an offer last week that could salvage the project. Cranley said he will continue construction if private sources will agree to cover the system’s operating costs for 30 years, eliminating any financial liability for the city.

Randy Simes at Urban Cincy says the streetcar is being held to an impossible standard that doesn’t apply to other city initiatives:

If the City of Cincinnati cannot afford any new financial liabilities, then will Mayor Cranley and his administration be requesting operating plans and financing for those new efforts from anything that comes to his desk? He has stated he wants to hire 200 new police officers, but who will shoulder the ongoing financial liability that will place on the City’s operating budget? Cranley has said he does not want to raise taxes, so that leaves only making cuts elsewhere to free up money for such a huge expansion of public safety forces.

In addition to the Cincinnati Streetcar, 200 new police officers and Westwood Square, this new heavy-handed approach will also jeopardize the Wasson Way Trail, future phases of Smale Riverfront Park, improvements to the city’s waste collection operations, rebuild of the Western Hills Viaduct, completion of the Ohio River Trail and development of the Eastern Corridor. This new standard will also put at risk what the Cranley Administration seems to hold as the Holy Grail of all local projects – the MLK Interchange.

Should we also expect a move by the Cranley Administration to stop all construction activities and spending on the Waldvogel Viaduct that is currently being rebuilt? That project has never submitted a financial report that estimates a 30-year operating cost, much less any private sources to cover those ongoing financial liability costs.

UrbanCincy certainly hopes that this is in fact not a new standard protocol at City Hall, because it will put a stop to virtually everything the City does and bring the delivery of public services to a screeching halt. If that is the case, then Mayor Cranley’s olive branch to streetcar supporters is nothing more than a massive double standard.

Elsewhere on the Network today: American Dirt marvels at the excess road capacity in Detroit. The Urbanophile highlights a recent study that examined why state legislatures tend not to pass bill that help big cities. And World Streets shares some wisdom from visionary Danish planner Jan Gehl about how to help people envision a different transportation paradigm.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Cincinnati Mayor Offers Last-Minute Plan to Save the Streetcar

|
Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley, who campaigned on the idea of killing the city’s under-construction streetcar, announced today he will allow the project to continue if operating costs can be funded through fares, advertising and private donations for the first 30 years. That’s the report from the Cincinnati Business Courier following the mayor’s big announcement this […]

Feds to Cincinnati: Resume Streetcar or Forfeit $40 Million

|
Hows does a politician justify spurning millions in federal grants out of supposed concern for the city’s budget? John Cranley, Cincinnati’s new mayor, handled that contradiction by telling voters there was some chance that if the city cancelled its federally-funded streetcar project, the money could be used for other things, like rebuilding an interchange. It […]

Cincinnati Will Complete Its Streetcar

|
“We’re gonna have a streetcar.” That was the announcement, met with cheers, from Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley this afternoon. With an active proposal in the City Council to resume construction on the streetcar, Cranley said he “would not sign the legislation because” he “thinks it’s wrong.” But he was flanked by Council Member Kevin Flynn, […]

John Cranley’s Cincinnati Streetcar Circus

|
The news out of Cincinnati continues to grow more absurd as recently elected Mayor John Cranley moves to kill a streetcar project that’s already under construction. The city of Cincinnati will pay almost $3 million a month to “pause” construction of its partially completed streetcar, following a vote by the City Council last night. Work […]