MIT Study: Benefits of Placemaking Go Deeper Than Better Places

StreetsAlive in Fargo and Moorhead, Minnesota, is changing attitudes about transportation beyond just two Sundays a week, organizers say. Image: ##http://www.fmspotlight.com/blog/streetsalive/##FMspotlight##

For two Sundays every summer, a three-mile loop between downtown Fargo, North Dakota and nearby Moorhead, Minnesota is transformed. The open streets event StreetsAlive draws between 6,000 and 8,000 people — on bikes, sneakers and rollerblades — into the space that is normally occupied by cars.

The event began as a healthy living initiative, with sponsorship from Blue Cross of Minnesota, managed by the Dakota Medical Foundation. But organizers say that as it has grown in popularity over the last three years, the event has evolved into something potentially transformative.

Local leaders are trying to use StreetsAlive to educate the public about the benefits of non-motorized transportation, and it seems to be working. Last year’s theme was “Life After Cars.” Embarking on a regional planning process, local officials reported high levels of support for amenities like bike lanes.

“People see this as a fun event, and we see it as the beginning of a conversation about better transportation,” Jill Chamberlain, a funding officer from Blue Cross Minnesota, told researchers at MIT recently.

Cleveland residents led the design of "Intersection Repair," cleaning and beautifying blighted areas. Image: Neighborhood Connections

“Placemaking” activities like this one — defined as the “deliberate shaping of an environment to facilitate social interaction and improve a community’s quality of life” — have important benefits that last far beyond when the street barriers are packed up and traffic returns, according to a new report by Susan Silberberg and her research team at MIT. According to their report — Places in the Making: How Placemaking Builds Places and Communities — the actual process of placemaking can be even more important than the physical outcome.

Open streets events, Park(ing) Day demonstrations, or a Better Block effort — these projects build social capital and empower citizens to drive change in their communities. And that can have a powerful impact long after the project’s completion.

“The act of advocating for change, questioning regulations, finding funding, and mobilizing others to contribute their voices engages communities — and in engaging, leaves these communities better for it,” Silberberg writes.

Rather than focusing solely on the physical outcome of a placemaking project — a park design, for example — Silberberg and her team say it’s important to recognize that these projects tend to be ongoing. Public spaces are never really “finished” anyway, they say, but rely on ongoing adaptation and maintenance from the community.

Another case study examined the “Intersection Repair” project in Cleveland. This process began with a series of meetings and a design party, involving community leaders and neighborhood residents.

One of the outcomes was the resign of Newark Alley, a dark, overgrown passage in the city’s working-class Stockyards Neighborhood. An elderly neighborhood resident remembered when the area was home to a stream and orchard. That memory inspired the final design, which is painted to look like a river.

The process also included mural painting and improvements across the neighborhood. One of the benches was painted with an inspirational message that gets to the heart of what’s at stake here: “You don’t have to move to live in a better neighborhood.”

In this sense, placemaking projects offer a welcome contrast to the planning dynamics of previous decades, which were characterized by top-down mega-projects led by impenetrable bureaucracies. The newer approach to planning — of which placemaking is a part — is inherently more democratic, more immediate and smaller-scale.

  • John Bailey

    Good stuff, but Fargo is in North Dakota not Minnesota.

  • Thanks! I knew that, I swear. 😉

  • Ted King

    May I suggest the following : “Fargo (ND) and nearby Moorhead (MN)” ? I also came across the blog post below. It has some links for bicycle resources in that area.

    Bicycle-friendly Fargo-Moorhead
    http://www.fargomoorhead.org/blog/?p=242

  • davistrain

    Thanks for supplying a definition of “placemaking”. I’ve seen the term as an element of “urbanist jargon” with a relatively nebulous meaning. “You don’t have to move to live in a better neighborhood” is certainly a call to action.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

How Does Your State Stack Up on Funding for Walking and Biking?

|
How well does your state fund infrastructure for walking and biking? Or perhaps we should say, how poorly? The Alliance for Biking and Walking put together this handy chart, showing roughly what proportion of each state’s federal funding goes toward projects for walking and biking. Obviously, no state is really rolling out the red carpet […]
Photo: Erik Voss and the Atlanta Bicycle Coalition via the Better Bike Share Partnership

Bike-Share and Open Streets: A Perfect Match

|
Open streets events, or ciclovias, give people a new way to explore their city's streets. Without cars on the streets, they're a natural opportunity for people who don't usually ride a bike to hop on two wheels -- and that's precisely why it's important to include bike-share systems in the mix, says Stefani Cox at the Better Bike Share Partnership.

New Report Examines the Media’s Role in the Gas Tax Debate

|
(Chart: University of Vermont Transportation Research Center) The success of state-level plans to increase gas taxes is tied to the media’s portrayal of the proposals in question, with narratives tied to "crumbling infrastructure" and "economic progress" showing more success than those emphasizing long-term transportation budget gaps, according to a new report released by the University […]