Public Interest Group Makes Progress in Case Against Transit Patent Troll

Martin Kelly Jones makes his living suing transit agencies and other entities for violating his patents on real-time tracking technology. His lawsuits have been an expensive nuisance for the companies and agencies he sues, usually settling for $50,000 to $75,000. But a movement to stop him is gaining traction.

Patent trolls stifle innovations like real-time transit tracking, which makes transit more efficient for riders. Photo: ##http://support.google.com/transitpartners/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=2529187##Google##

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, in its quest to invalidate patents that hinder innovation, has been looking for what’s called “prior art.” Prior art is evidence that an idea existed and was in circulation before someone else patented it. EFF thinks they’ve found it.

Last week, EFF and attorneys at Berkeley Law School filed a request with the United States Patent and Trademark Office, urging the office to re-examine the legitimacy of Jones’ patent on real-time tracking technology.

“Even if you could patent something that broad and vague – and we think you can’t – you certainly can’t patent something that was invented by other people years before,” said EFF Staff Attorney Julie Samuels.

EFF says they’ve got their “prior art”:

ArrivalStar [one of Jones’ offshore companies] claims its patents are based on an invention from 1999 and argues that many widely used transit-tracking systems – as well as some package-tracking services used by delivery and shipping companies – are infringing. But in the reexamination request filed today, EFF and the Samuelson Clinic show that as far back as 1992, public technical reports described a “Smart Bus system” that used the same methods as those included in the ArrivalStar patent.

EFF found a U.S. DOT technical report from 1992 that describes just the kind of vehicle tracking in the patent, according to details provided by David Alpert at Greater Greater Washington. “News articles talk about the Nextbus company’s product, which also does this, from 1996. Yet the patent office granted Patent #7,030,781 in 1999 2006, but with a ‘priority date,’ the date before which prior art is relevant, of 1999 or 1993.”

Patent trolls — people who don’t make or sell anything but hold on to patents so they can sue anyone that does — put a chill on innovation. In this case, they disincentivize transit agencies from providing information that makes their service far more appealing and easy to use. We all pay the price of low transit ridership in the form of traffic congestion, safety hazards, air pollution, and decreased mobility. EFF, Berkeley, and all the other advocates and attorneys working to stop patent trolling are doing us all a favor.

  • Joe

    “We all pay the price of low transit ridership in the form of traffic congestion, safety hazards, air pollution, and decreased mobility.” True. We also all pay the price because it’s taxpayer money that funds settlements and legal fees for public transit agencies. I suspect that the actual damage is much more than has been reported. I don’t know if there’s a record of settlements made before a lawsuit is filed.

  • LYP

    LYP-I appreciate for your kind and generous sharing.Shop online at christian louboutin mall for a great selection of christian louboutin boots, christian wedding shoes,christian louboutin ankle boots and sandals for girls,women and men with free shopping on all orders.Welcome to luxury christian louboutin sale online store.The best christian louboutin at best price, free delivery,easy returns & exchanges,100% quality guarantee!Save 82% Off.Cheap christian louboutin daffodile makes a woman’s feet dazzle and shine even after the twelve strikes of midnight.Own a pair of stylish and wonderful christian louboutin is women’s lifetime pursuit. We offer christian louboutin red bottom shoes online shopping by an elegant but easy way. Shopping online at discount price for red sole signature designer.
    Order  products in christian louboutin sale store are free shipping.If you want to be more remarkable,do not miss christian louboutin daffodil. They are sexy and gorgeous christian louboutin.Welcome old and new customers,we will offer you the best service.All shoes has been worked by good craftsman and christian louboutin men for men by hand and this is the result of a careful selection.If you   are engaged in the vogue or you want keep the same pace with the trend,christian louboutin could be your best choice.It is really nice of you to share the excellent shoes information to others. christian louboutin shoes is absolutely representative of fashion and recreation,became a matter of course the popular protagonist of the season.christian louboutin outlet will try our best to satisfy you christian louboutin wedges.
    christian louboutin sale is french hot brand in the world,We provide different kinds of christian louboutin usa.Choose the   woman wearing louboutin slingback,often has realised that many men somehow to high-heeled shoes have deep interest,wear cheap christian louboutin sales shoes can easily outright conquest many men,can easily get many men worship,can easily make many men excited.In fashionable arena occupies a place   of christian louboutin ankle boot forever and always makes women fascination.christian louboutin outlet
     foot that one wipe enthusiastic red,no matter how plain clothes,they   were unable to hide the hostess as fire the lively personality.christian louboutin sandals is fashionable and beautiful, recently new appearance of new women’s   sandals,presenting an one colour profusion,design and material   collocation also ingenuity, pretty,both restoring ancient ways,full of female lasting appeal,sweet call a person fondle admiringly
    christian louboutin shoes sole design very clever,”catch” the selling point of sight let woman enchanted,sexy very narcissistic is frowsty coquettish,imagine a man to follow his sole after the line of sight of red,women must have is willing to pay. The identification of the “red sole degree is high,it’s another benefit is let female stars free advertising.christian louboutin sale shoes as a woman’s external wearing choice embodies her connotation,her taste,her pursuit of her life,understanding.christian louboutin sandals is a woman’s life cannot resist temptation of summer follow sandal high is undoubtedly the most powerful-naked fiber foot,Dan red nutmeg, summer air fragrance in stimulating fashion masters of inspiration,the perfect cheap christian louboutin daffodile,in people the envy of look in the eyes supports a pieces of living color.Delicate the luxury of girl for oneself of each clothes to acquire a   pair of high heels to match,but always than a double take christian louboutin 2012 to reality.
    Whether you are what kind of woman need to wear a pair of christian louboutin shoes on the red carpet,your choice,we are unable to intervene,but you should know that Mr.Bhutto’s name.christian louboutin outlet today has five stores in the United States,two in New York the rest of South Beach Plaza in Los Angeles,Las Vegas and Orange state,some christian louboutin sale stores are planning to open in the Bal harbour,Boston and Chicago.The famous U.S. talk show host Oprah Winfrey,christian louboutin sandals is an art,recent and famous director David Lynch co-operation,his collection of shoes do one called "Idol"exhibition.R &B singer Ciara,Jay-Z’s song with the lyrics of christian louboutin canada content.
    Red soled christian louboutin shoes‘s signature logo,highlighting women’s lovely,beautiful,quieter and mature sexy christian louboutin sale store favorite with a variety of bright colors,especially open-toed style won him favor with the soleNama red flag,the performance of a woman with high heels the sexiest,swaying side.No wonder so many stars are even willing to free to speak for him,showed off alone belong to the christian louboutin outlet‘s style on the red carpet.Frenchman christian louboutin sales world is absolutely impossible to ignore.It is a favorite of European and American actress!”Red shoes” to identify high,another advantage is that the female stars free advertising.See the red soles of christian louboutin uk,the fundamental need to find the logo.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

APTA Goes After Transit-Harassing Patent Troll

|
For years, transit agencies and other companies have been harassed by a patent troll seeking to extort them for “settlements” when they use real-time vehicle tracking technologies. ArrivalStar and Melvino Technologies, offshore firms led by one Martin Kelly Jones, claim to hold the rights to those ideas. Jones has been picking off agencies one by one […]

Patent Troll Sues Transit Agencies For Releasing Real-Time Transit Info

|
Lloyd Dobbler, John Cusack’s generation-defining character in Say Anything, notably said, “I don’t want to sell anything, buy anything, or process anything as a career.” Martin Kelly Jones lives by a similar creed. He doesn’t make or sell anything. Instead he makes his living by attacking transit agencies for using real-time tracking technologies that he […]

Notorious Patent Troll Forced to Stop Targeting Transit Agencies

|
A patent troll who persistently sued transit agencies for using technology that gives passengers real-time arrival information won’t harass any more transit providers under the terms of a settlement reached in federal court yesterday. The firm known as ArrivalStar — led by a patent holder named Martin Kelley Jones — had sued 11 local transit […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Will Amtrak’s Hoosier State Line Keep Running Once Fed Funds Run Out? (Post-Tribune, JC Online) Rep. Denham May Have Tripped Over Himself in Attempt to Block High-Speed Rail (Sac Bee) APTA Settles Case With Patent Troll Who’s Been Suing Public Transit Agencies (Ars Technica) Oberstar’s Advice for White House on Transpo? Go Around Congress (Politico MT) […]

Seattle Mayor: “More Choices Means Fewer Cars on Our Streets”

|
On Monday, Mayor Ed Murray unveiled “Move Seattle” — a 10-year vision for transportation that synthesizes planning for street safety, transit, and bicycling. “More choices means fewer cars on our streets,” Murray said when announcing the plan. “That means, when you do need to drive, you’ll be up against less traffic. And with roads less […]

Lawmakers Fret About Impact of Budget Cuts on Transit

|
“In 2014, federal investment in surface transportation — which is currently about $50 billion per year — will drop to $6 billion or $7 billion. In one year.” Those were the dire words spoken by Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) at the start of this morning’s Transportation & Infrastructure Committee hearing on MAP-21. What he meant […]