In NYC & Florida, Asking Police to Step Up for Pedestrian and Cyclist Safety

It’s been unsettling, to say the least, to read about the New York City Police Department’s sloppy investigation of the hit-and-run crash that killed cyclist Mathieu Lefevre last fall. Today the New York City Council is holding a hearing that will examine NYPD’s practices when it comes to investigating pedestrian and cyclist deaths.

The parents of Mathieu Lefevre speak at a rally held recently at NYPD headquarters. Photo copyright ##Dmitry Gudkov## http://gudphoto.com/bikenyc/2011/10/26/rally-for-traffic-justice/##

The issue of police treatment of pedestrians and cyclists is one that safe streets advocates all over the country grapple with on a regular basis.

Bike advocate Dan Moser argued recently in Florida Weekly that many law enforcement officials still operate under the assumption that cyclists and pedestrians are at fault in collisions because they don’t belong on the roads. In his column, reprinted at Network blog WalkBikeLee, Moser says its time for greater understanding and change:

From the time I worked in the injury prevention program at a public health agency, where dissecting crash data in order to determine countermeasures to prevent future injury and death was among my duties, I became acutely aware of the second-class treatment non-motorists receive in crash investigations. Law enforcement agencies (some are worse offenders than others) seem to operate under the premise that our roadways and bridges are first and foremost for motor vehicles, thus nonmotorists have some degree of fault when a crash occurs simply by virtue of being where we don’t belong. This mindset must change or Florida’s dubious distinction of being the most dangerous state for cyclists and pedestrians in the country will continue.

Stating this, I’m risking my working relationship with some in law enforcement who will take it personally. But those of us who are striving to improve conditions for exposed road users (and there are many) aren’t looking to criticize for the sake of criticism, but rather offering our expertise and insight to help solve a chronic problem. I’d like to think anyone who’s truly committed to doing the same will look to us as a resource and take advantage of what we offer rather than consider us whiners and discontents who are only trying to justify the unpredictable behavior sometimes practiced by the vulnerable among us.

My plea is for our law enforcement agencies to take us up on our offer to assist them in doing their job. We’re not attempting to tell you how to do it, only to help you better understand our plight and the frustration we face so you can make our roads safer and easier for all users to navigate. Granted, law enforcement is only part of the solution, but it’s a vital element that clearly needs improvement.

How fairly would you say your local police department treats traffic crashes involving pedestrians and cyclists?

Elsewhere on the Network today: PubliCola asks whether 28 Seattle-area pedestrians would be alive today had the city taken advantage of existing opportunities for road diets. Bicyclelaw.com offers ten tips for drivers interacting with cyclists. And NRDC Switchboard compares the House transportation bill to the Titanic.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Colorado Authorities Cite Driver for Cyclist Harassment

|
Despite the number of two-wheeled cop patrols around some cities, police aren’t always the most bike-minded bunch. When there’s a conflict between motorists and cyclists, they’re often inclined to take the motorist’s side. As Streetsblog has reported, police in New York City care more about drunk pedestrians than unsafe drivers, despite the fact that most fatalities are caused by […]

“Summer Streets” Aren’t Enough

|
New York has them. San Francisco has them. Portland, too. Now St. Louis might be getting its own version of Summer Streets. Streetsblog Network member St. Louis Urban Workshop is happy with Mayor Francis Slay’s proposal to close some of the city’s streets to motor vehicles on summer weekends. But the blog calls for more […]

Will New Haven Replace a Highway With Highway-Like Conditions?

|
Around the Network today: Will Cars Dominate New Haven’s Post-Highway Development? Sustainability advocates cheered the city of New Haven’s plan to tear down a 1.1 mile stretch of highway near downtown, opening up space for a walkable mixed-use development on 10 acres of newly available land. The project was considered so innovative it was awarded […]

London Is Going to Ban the Deadliest Trucks From Its Streets

|
Heavy trucks with big blind spots are a deadly menace to cyclists and pedestrians. In Boston, eight of the nine cyclist fatalities between 2012 and 2014 involved commercial vehicles, according to the Boston Cyclists Union [PDF]. Between June and September this year, there were six cyclist fatalities in Chicago, and all six involved commercial vehicles. In New York City, drivers […]

Almost Every State Chooses to Retain Recreational Trails Funding

|
Since Congress passed a disappointing transportation bill in June, all eyes have been on the states, which were granted new leeway to forgo investments in safe walking and biking. This week, sustainable transportation advocates have at least one encouraging sign. Almost every state has chosen to put its federal “recreational trails” funding to use. Sam […]