What If Roads Really Did Have to Pay for Themselves?

pittsburgh_bus.jpgPittsburgh’s bus system is far from the only subsidized transportation in Pennsylvania. Photo: Port Authority

Pittsburgh area residents are reeling from the news this week that their transit agency, the Port Authority of Allegheny County, may cut 35 percent of its total service in January — and raise fares — unless the state of Pennsylvania can come up with new funding for transportation. The massive amputation would come on top of a 15 percent cut three years ago, reducing the transit network to a shadow of its former self.

The funding crisis has intensified since April, when the feds rejected a bid from Governor Ed Rendell to raise money by tolling Interstate 80. The solutions Rendell is floating now, including a tax on oil company profits or raising the state gas tax a few cents, are meeting resistance from rural legislators who don’t like the idea of spending part of the revenues on transit.

Streetsblog Network member the East Busway Blog says bring on the transportation starvation, as long as it cuts both ways:

I am 100% in support of pulling all state
funding from the Port Authority (and SEPTA for that matter) with the
caveat that the state no longer maintain any roads or fund any new
roads. Counties and municipalities would be on
the hook to maintain all existing roads and fund any new road
construction or expansion, to include limited access highways without
the help of state funds.

It’s hard to hypothesize what this would
be like because it is unprecedented.  It’s even harder to imagine how
it would be all funded; not a pretty scenario given our auto-centric
society.

The Busway blogger’s thought experiment, which involves a look at Colorado’s privately financed and managed highway, E-470, and an assortment of new tolls and taxes that motorists would have to absorb, leads him to this conclusion:

So,
once again, anyone willing to trade privatized transit for privatized
roads, I’m all for it.  That way everyone can finally see that no form
of human transportation, be it automotive, rail, air, or bus is
un-subsidized.

More from around the Network: The Congress for the New Urbanism’s report on replacing New Orleans’ Claiborne Expressway with an urban boulevard is generating a stir in St. Louis and Seattle, where the future of downtown freeways is a hot topic. Transit in Utah links back to an important Citiwire story about the benefits of mixed-use development for city tax revenues. And Transit Miami is watchdogging a Florida DOT project that should make a commercial corridor more walkable and bikeable.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

In the Midst of Seattle’s Transit Crisis, a Money Grab for Roads

|
Despite some horrendous transit cuts looming in Seattle, the Washington legislature can’t seem to get a transportation budget passed, reports Josh Feit at PubliCola. The state’s Democrats and Republicans are struggling to reach an agreement, he says, and a recent budget proposal from two lawmakers helps explain the impasse. As Seattle Metro riders brace for […]

Maryland on the Verge of a Fix for Transportation Funding Woes

|
Maryland is one of a growing number of U.S. states that’s found itself in a tough spot when it comes to transportation funding. The state blew through its transportation funds when it built a big highway project called the Intercounty Connector. Now, the state has so little money left that unless something changes, it won’t be […]

Pennsylvania’s Bid to Toll I-80 Rejected by Feds

|
Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell (D) has scheduled a press conference this afternoon to discuss his pitch for new tolls on Interstate 80, but local media reports are already suggesting that his news is not good: the federal government has rejected the state’s bid to toll the highway, leaving its transportation budget short at least $450 […]

The State of State Transit Funding

|
States increased their transit spending more than 5 percent between 2007 and 2011, reaching $13.9 billion annually, according to a recent report from the Association of American State Highway and Transportation Officials. But that increase was concentrated in just a handful of states. Almost all of the elevated transit spending — 92 percent — is attributable to five […]

Yes, Transit Belongs in the Highway Trust Fund

|
As gas tax revenues wane, making it harder to finance a long-term transportation bill, ideas are beginning to circulate about how to save the (very poorly named) Highway Trust Fund. Some say the gas tax needs to rise. Others say fewer programs need to be financed out of the fund, which pays for all federal […]