Nevada Becomes Newest Battleground in Mileage Tax Debate

Nevada’s state DOT is in the early stages of a years-long study aimed at mapping a possible transition from the gas tax to a vehicle miles traveled (VMT) fee, a shift urged last year by a congressionally chartered panel on infrastructure financing and encouraged by Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-OR).

GPS_tax_mileage.jpgIn-vehicle GPS units, such as the one above, are often discussed as a method for tracking VMT. (Photo: JustGetThere)

But after the first of the state’s two public hearings on the study, the very idea of evaluating an eventual VMT tax is proving to be polarizing and politically risky.

The Nevada chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union has decried the study as a privacy risk, raising "serious questions about any VMT proposal that would set up what
amounts to a perfect infrastructure for tracking citizens everywhere
they go in their vehicles," while two regional transportation commissions have withdrawn funding from the effort.

The Nevada Motor Transport Association, a trade group representing trucking and bus companies, also has spoken out against the concept of VMT charges, while business and labor interests are countering with support for the study under the umbrella of the Nevada Highway Users Coalition (not connected to the American Highway Users Alliance).

Local road users, meanwhile, appear to be divided on the merits of a move from gas taxes to mileage-based charging. From the Reno Gazette-Journal:

Gasing
up one recent afternoon at a Reno service station, [Luiz] Garcia said he would
probably be open to a mileage-based fee system to raise needed road
funding.

"It seems like that would be fair," said Garcia, 48. "If you use, you have to pay."

Scott
Deupree, 62, said he would be open to considering the possibility but
would want to be sure fees wouldn’t be added to existing gas taxes for
an overall tax increase "on the sly."Roads
"have got to be taken care of" and if a mileage fee is the most
efficient way to do so, it might be a reasonable step, said 25-year-old
Brandon Rasmussen of Carson City.

  • Fran Lynch

    I think this is totally unconstitutional, ridiculous and shows just how greedy the current government is!!!! /stop bleeding your neighbors and citizens dry! Stop government wasteful spending is where you will find all the money YOU need to clean up the mess your in.

    Former Nevada citizen

  • Kylie

    Some of us live in rural towns where our jobs are 50 plus miles away. We live where we do because of the crime in the towns where we work and the opportunity to raise our children with out the corruption of the bigger cities.  Why should we be punished for our choice by paying a usage fee??

  • Medical Solutions

    IT Management & Support KBCSI
    offers a wide variety of IT solutions below are two of our featured solutions Medical Solutions KBCSI has developed a specialized program specific to the
    medical and health care industry. Thanks for the Microsoft CRM Dynamics mention and I put your link up here too.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Blumenauer: Let’s Stop Hiding in Fear of a Mileage Fee

|
In June, the House of Representatives voted to ban U.S. DOT from even studying the viability of switching from the gas tax to a vehicle-miles-traveled (VMT) fee. But the tide may be turning: The sponsor of the amendment, Rep. Chip Cravaack, has been ousted from Congress, the amendment itself is on the skids, and a new […]

Ten Questions (and Answers) About Oregon’s New VMT Charge

|
This summer, Oregon’s legislature passed a bill creating a vehicle-miles-traveled fee. For those who recognize the shortcomings of the gas tax for charging for road use, it was a big victory. But the program authorized by the state is a modest one, creating a voluntary program for just 5,000 drivers of high-efficiency vehicles. ODOT’s Jim […]

The Gas Tax Versus a VMT Tax: Is ‘All of the Above’ an Option?

|
(Chart: Oregon DOT) The prospect of an eventual move away from the gas tax and towards a fee on vehicle miles traveled (VMT) has sparked consternation from some well-known bloggers this week, with Matt Yglesias asserting that "a VMT [tax] has no advantages whatsoever over higher gasoline taxes" and Andrew Samwick suggesting that declining fuel […]