A Common Thread in the Home Buyer’s Tax Credit and ‘Cash for Clunkers’

Back in the days of "cash for clunkers," which saw the Obama administration send nearly $3 billion in taxpayer-funded rebates to boost the sagging auto industry, our Ryan Avent and several other economics wonks pointed out an inconvenient fact: Many participants in the program would have bought cars anyway, and the rebates only pulled their purchases forward in time.

Now it seems that the tax credit for new home buyers, opened up to even existing homeowners as part of an $11 billion expansion passed in November, is having a similar effect on the homebuilding industry.

As MarketWatch reports from the Las Vegas International Building Show, homebuilders are still mourning the housing bubble that popped so perilously as subprime mortgages imploded, but they are cautiously optimistic about this year as compared with 2009. Still, mitigating factors persist — and here’s one:

Payback from the expiration of the home-buyer tax credit.
"The tax credit is pulling people forward who were in the market
anyway. So the sales pace isn’t quite as vibrant as suggested by the
raw data. There could be a payback that materializes (in July) when the
current version expires," Sullivan said.

Unless, to the chagrin of environmental groups and many, many voters who rent, Congress decides to extend the sprawl-enticing tax credit one more time in the summer. Lawmakers are often reluctant to let temporary tax credits fade away when industries are lobbying in favor of their extension — even if the underlying economic logic is demonstrably shoddy.

And if Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood’s comments at the Detroit Auto Show this month are any guide ("You see no criticism of ‘cash for clunkers’ in America"), even the auto rebates could make a return.

  • mike

    I hate anything to do with Cash4Clunkers. Here we are pushing new cars into a market already saturated with countless used and repossessed cars (i.e. repofinder.com). Now new cars depreciate faster, more Americans are in debt, and more repossessions are on the horizon.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Could Electric-Car Tax Credits Become the Next “Cash for Clunkers”?

|
The White House’s commitment to electrified cars, fulfilling an Obama campaign promise to put 1 million plug-in hybrids into service by 2015, is bound to have serious ramifications for the nation’s already-crumbling system of paying for transportation. (Photo: MPR) But could the administration continue to leave the gas tax untouched while relying on taxpayer-subsidized rebates […]

House Quickly Sends $2 Billion More to ‘Cash for Clunkers’

|
The "cash for clunkers" rebate program, which promises new auto buyers up to $4,500 for fuel-efficiency upgrades as small as 2 miles per gallon, is back to life after burning through $1 billion in taxpayer cash. Minutes ago, the House approved $2 billion more in auto rebates by transferring cash that was already headed for […]

A Better — and Cooler — Version of “Cash for Clunkers”

|
(Photo: Free Press) During the Senate’s debate over giving $2 billion more to the "cash for clunkers" car rebate program, John McCain (R-AZ) quipped that "cash for refrigerators" might be next in line. Does McCain know that it’s already happening — with a much bigger environmental boost than the auto version? In Michigan, the Detroit […]