Why Urban Residents Have a Bone to Pick With Vitter and Bennett

In a development that flew largely under the radar on Thursday, the Senate beat back an attempt by David Vitter (R-LA) and Bob Bennett (R-UT) to add a citizenship question to the 2010 U.S. Census, with the goal of no longer counting non-citizens as part of states’ official populations.

sen_vitter.jpgSen. David Vitter (R-LA) (Photo: Chattahbox)

The Vitter-Bennett proposal would have had a significant effect on the reapportionment of congressional seats that occurs after every decennial Census, with independent demographers predicting a loss of five seats for California and one each for New York and Illinois. 

On the whole, metropolitan areas where immigrants are strongly represented — think large, blue-state cities — would be disproportionately impacted. Leaving aside the troubling symbolism of no longer counting non-citizens,  Vitter-Bennett also would likely cause a major shift in the distribution of federal transportation funds, a sizable chunk of which are given out according to population-based formulas.

So urban residents can rest easy knowing that the Senate defeated the Vitter-Bennett plan, right?

Maybe not. The clash over how the Census should count immigrant residents is still raging, and Democratic strategist Simon Rosenberg said last month that he expects "the Republican assault on the Census and reapportionment" to continue apace.

And although Vitter-Bennett never came to an up-or-down vote last week, it’s worth looking at the vote to close off debate on the spending bill that served as a vehicle for the the Census issue. Every Republican voted to keep debating the bill, leaving the door open for Vitter-Bennett to be considered.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Vitter Seeks to Cut Environmental Reviews for Massive Road Projects

|
Bridges are getting a lot of attention as senators add their two cents to the upper chamber’s transportation budget proposal for next year. The Senate transportation appropriations bill includes $500 million for “bridges in critical corridors” (BRICC), designed as a response to the recent bridge collapse along I-5 in Washington state — home of Senator […]

Montana Dem Max Baucus to Chair Senate Transpo Subcommittee

|
We at Streetsblog have been saying that the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee will be a key player in the transportation debate this session, counterbalancing the conservative House as they, together with the administration and the Senate Banking Committee, craft a six-year reauthorization. The EPW could play a key role in tempering House attempts […]