The Dirty Secret of Coal Ash: It’s in Our Roads


Watch CBS News Videos Online

Last night’s 60 Minutes featured an eye-opening report (viewable above) on the 130 million tons of coal ash waste generated every year by the nation’s thirst for energy. The show outlined the lack of oversight over disposal of the toxic ash, which is routinely used in the most commonplace of areas: concrete.

In its fact sheet on fly ash — as the by-products of coal burning is sometimes called — the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) touts the "economic and ecological benefits" of using the substance in the asphalt that paves U.S. roadways.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has joined the effort by partnering with industry interests on the Coal Combustion Projects Partnership, which has the stated goal of "decreasing greenhouse gas emissions from avoided cement manufacturing" by using coal ash as an additive — notwithstanding the emissions that created the coal ash in the first place.

Using coal ash in local streets, making concrete stronger and cheaper to produce has become an accepted practice because the mixing process is thought to trap the toxic ingredients. But in the wake of last year’s massive coal ash spill in Tennessee, environmental groups are raising questions about possible public health risks and the EPA is signaling it will begin regulating the ash.

A final decision on new rules for coal ash is expected by December, EPA chief Lisa Jackson told 60 Minutes yesterday. Still, it’s worth noting that concrete companies are already pushing back against the idea, warning that the bills for local transportation projects would swell even if the EPA continues to consider roads a "beneficial" use for coal ash.

During Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood’s appearance in the House infrastructure committee late last week, Rep. Howard Coble (R-NC) queried him on the prospect of coal ash regulation. Coble said:

I also understand that EPA may consider a hybrid approach to regulating the material so that the beneficial use of fly ash is deemed non-hazardous but the material that remains would be classified hazardous. We’ve been advised that if the EPA decides to implement either of these approaches, concrete producers would have to use an average of more than 15 to 20 percent more cement per yard of concrete to replace the fly ash.

Could concrete producers successfully lobby to water down the impact of the EPA’s move? In a city where every industry has sway in the race for campaign cash, it’s certainly possible.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Getting to Know the Senate Conferees

|
The Senate unveiled its list of conference committee delegates yesterday to a widespread lack of surprise. Ten of the 14 conferees are either chair or ranking member of a committee (or subcommittee) charged with writing part of the Senate transportation bill. Their job will be to defend their work from a House delegation that has […]

The New Way to “Screw Obama” — Poisoning Your Neighbors’ Air

|
Warning: The crazies are getting crazier. Behold the new depth to which macho car culture, blatant anti-environmentalism, and Obama hating has sunk. “Coal rollers” retrofit their pickup trucks to “trick” the diesel engines into thinking they need more gas. The result: big, billowing plumes of black smoke — the better to spew at Priuses and […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Oberstar: Midwest is ahead of California in high-speed rail planning (MinnPost) D.C. Metro chief rejects proposal to phase out rail cars that are subject to tax-shelter leases; instead, the cars will be sandwiched between newer models (WJLA) Biden heads to Colorado today to tout a new bike path that the state DOT is building with […]

Boxer and Mica Release Vague Reassurance of Progress

|
Sen. Barbara Boxer and Rep. John Mica just released this statement: The conferees have moved forward toward a bipartisan, bicameral agreement on a highway reauthorization bill.  Both House and Senate conferees will continue to work with a goal of completing a package by next week. From what we’re hearing, whatever deal they’ve reached only applies […]

Study: Electric Cars Not So Green Unless Powered by Renewables

|
A study by the government of the Australian state of Victoria highlights the limits of electric cars, in isolation, to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The Victorian government’s ongoing “electric vehicle trial” [PDF] found that electric cars powered by coal may actually produce more carbon emissions than petroleum-fueled cars over the lifetime of the vehicle, from manufacturing […]

House Defies Veto Threat, Passes Drill-And-Drive Extension

|
In a brazen but expected display of defiance — both of the President and of bipartisan efforts in the Senate — the House voted today to extend transportation policy through the end of September with several contentious policy changes attached. The bill, whose name (The Surface Transportation Extension Act of 2012, Part II) reads like the […]