New ‘Clunkers’ Analysis: Trucks, SUVs More Popular Than Suggested

When the Obama administration first called for more "cash for clunkers" last week, two influential senators said they could not back an extension without stronger efficiency standards for the program’s trade-ins — only to drop their opposition after viewing U.S. DOT sales figures that showed buyers snapping up gas-sipping cars.

1097.jpgIs this Ford Escape the real winner of "cash for clunkers"? (Photo: InfoBarrel)

But as it turns out, those figures relied on a bit of fuzzy (and Environmental Protection Agency-approved) math. Vehicles were separated according to 4WD, 2WD, and hybrid varieties, unlike more traditional auto-sales figures that tally all three, listing only the make and model.

When CNN enlisted independent auto-industry trackers at Edmunds.com to project the sales figures if all engine varieties counted as a single vehicle, a funny thing happened: The top "clunkers" seller went from the efficient Toyota Corolla to the Ford Escape SUV.

The Escape is available as a hybrid, which gets 29 miles per gallon and 11.8 barrels in average annual oil consumption, according to the government’s fuel-economy tracker. The Corolla gets identical scores.

But the Escape’s conventional varieties get 22 and 24 mpg, with much higher oil use estimates.

The Edmunds.com study also found that two full-size trucks, the Ford F-150 and Chevy Silverado, would rank in the "clunkers" top 10 if the DOT counted their multiple varieties as a single vehicle. The Silverado gets either 15 or 17 mpg, depending on the engine type, while the F-150 gets between 16 and 17 mpg.

In contrast to the DOT’s sales list, which ranked foreign-made cars in six of the top 10 spots, Edmunds.com’s adjusted list found that eight of the top 10 most-purchased vehicles were GM, Ford, or Chrysler.

  • You can either Lease or buy a new car to use the cash for clunkers program. It has to be new vehicles and not used ones.

    Henry
    Blogger
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info

  • For working trucks the rule is not based on the fuel efficieny. As long as it is manufactured before 2001 they all qualify
    but cannot be older than 25 years old..

    Henry
    Blogger
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info

  • For working trucks the rule is not based on the fuel efficieny. As long as it is manufactured before 2001 they all qualify
    but cannot be older than 25 years old..

    Henry
    Blogger
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info
    http://www.cashforclunkersfacts.info

  • One can slice and dice vehicle makes, models and engine types endlessly. It’s not a productive argument. The bottom line question is, what is the net efficiency improvement and fuel savings from the cash for clunkers program? That’s what I’d like to find out.

  • Oliver

    Net efficiency of vehicles sold under program means even less than Corporate Average Fuel Efficiency.

    No subsidy should have been given to any vehicle getting less than 30 mpg. Period.

    Should we decide to save the manufacturers who make gas guzzling vehicles then lets have a program that does that. Should we decide to help out america’s work truck owners then fine lets do that. (oh wait isn’t that how every contractors wife got an Escalade 8 yrs ago in the first place?)

    Let’s not pretend that we’re greening up however while subsidizing 18 mpg trucks.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

House Quickly Sends $2 Billion More to ‘Cash for Clunkers’

|
The "cash for clunkers" rebate program, which promises new auto buyers up to $4,500 for fuel-efficiency upgrades as small as 2 miles per gallon, is back to life after burning through $1 billion in taxpayer cash. Minutes ago, the House approved $2 billion more in auto rebates by transferring cash that was already headed for […]

GAO: Economic Recovery Benefits of ‘Cash for Clunkers’ Are ‘Uncertain’

|
"Cash for clunkers," the White House’s much-touted program encouraging trade-ins for more fuel-efficient autos, had an "uncertain" impact on economic recovery, according to a new audit from the independent Government Accountability Office (GAO) — largely because it remains unclear how many of the car sales it spurred would have occurred without taxpayer subsidies. Were "clunker" […]

How to Judge “Cash for Clunkers”

|
(Photo: NYT) At this point, it’s difficult to know exactly what the government’s "cash for clunkers" program is supposed to accomplish. Claims about its economic and environmental benefits are increasingly detached from reality, and the chief advantage of the program would seem to be that it "worked," in the sense that it was popular among […]

Grassley Looking Into Citibank’s Million-Dollar ‘Clunkers’ Deal

|
Chuck Grassley (IA), the senior Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, today asked the U.S. DOT to answer a question Streetsblog Capitol Hill first wondered about months ago: How did Citibank, the beleaguered recipient of a $45 billion government bailout, snag a contract to administer the Obama administration’s "cash for clunkers" program? Sen. Chuck Grassley […]

‘Clunkers’ Consequences: GM Sales Down, Ford Gas-Guzzlers Up

|
When Congress tripled the size of the "cash for clunkers" program in July, both Congress and the White House billed the $3 billion program as a boon for struggling domestic automakers. But when those Detroit car companies released sales figures today, the numbers didn’t quite match up to the hype. (Photo: AFP/Getty) General Motors and […]